City Year reviews

3.4

53% would recommend to a friend

(2,292 total reviews)
avatar

Michael Brown

46% approve of CEO

41% positive business outlook

City Year has an employee rating of 3.4 out of 5 stars, based on 2,292 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The City Year employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Education industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

2K reviews
4.0
Nov 13, 2008
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

This rating is based on my experience as a senior corps member, NOT as a salaried employee: 1. Like other AmeriCorps programs, City Year gives you a chance to learn a variety of skills while helping your community. Personally, I got to try my hand at volunteer coordination, college and career counseling, event planning, teaching, and more. 2. City Year also carefully measures its impact, so you know that your organization is actually accomplishing its mission. 3. When it comes to advancement, many corps members go on to a second year or to become salaried employees. There is a network of sites across the United States, so many corps members and employees go on to work in different cities. City Year prefers hiring from amongst its former corps members, so advancement opportunities up into the salaried level are many. 4. City Year also knows that you have a life outside of City Year. If you need to, it is considered okay to get a part-time job while you are a corps member to supplement your living stipend. If you have children, you may be eligible for a childcare stipend.

Cons

This rating is based on my experience as a senior corps member, NOT as a salaried employee: 1. Due to the high number of corps members of a wide variety of ages (17-24), City Year provides very little freedom and, in some cases, respect to its corps members. At the end of term convention, staff members literally did "bed checks" to make sure everyone was in their room. For someone who'd been out of college a couple of years, this was horrifying! 2. The insurance provided is TERRIBLE. The company used mostly caters to school athletic programs. Corps members make very little money as part of the program, but services like prescriptions must be paid up front and then reimbursed. The insurance company is very unresponsive and known for cutting off payment in error. Two years later I am still trying to get a bill paid. 3. City Year is very inexperienced in dealing with medical emergencies. Staff members, including Human Resources, are uneducated in laws regarding "perceived disability." It is possible that service members/corps members are an exempt population, but I have no knowledge about that either way. Anyway, what this means is that if it is -perceived- that you are disabled, you will be treated as such. Also, staff member attitude toward safety is at times cavalier.

1.0
Nov 9, 2008
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

If you are passionate about community service and working with youth and don't mind sitting around for hours on end doing nothing or a frustrating workplace.

Cons

If you have a problem upper management will turn it around on you. Basically, there is nothing wrong with City Year, the problem is you. Time is not managed well at all. Expect to find yourself with nothing to do for hours on end. No one cares if the other people on your team do nothing; a lazy work ethic is considered "diversity" there. Whatever happened to Americorps:Getting things done? Also, the pay is incredibly poor but you do get an education award.

3.0
Nov 4, 2008
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Professional development skills Networking opportunities Meet like-minded people your age Looks good on a resume Education award Learning to work with all types of people (personality-wise, but also cultural differences)

Cons

Education award is severely limited. Not only is it taxable, it is only applicable to federal loans in good standing. Also, if you work for a second year, you may no longer be eligible for loan deferment and since you won't get the ed award until the end of your term, it's pretty useless. It is also not applicable to any bills you may have acquired from courses taken prior to your year of service (i.e. if you serve from 08-09, you can't make payments toward classes from Summer 2008 or any time earlier than that).

Viewing 2290 - 2292 of 2,292 Reviews

Glassdoor has 2,502 City Year reviews submitted anonymously by City Year employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if City Year is right for you.