Wouldn't recommend - Anonymous employee Butternut Box Employee Review

1.0
Feb 25, 2025
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

free dog food good holiday

Cons

Butternut Box presents itself as a company built on values like genuine care and open and honest communication, but the reality doesn’t always match the branding. While the mission is great, there’s a noticeable gap between the culture they promote and the experience of employees. Nepotism is a real issue at the senior leadership level, with promotions and key decisions often favoring personal connections over merit. This creates a frustrating environment where talent and hard work go unnoticed. Transparency is also lacking, as difficult conversations are avoided rather than addressed openly. If you’re looking for a workplace that truly lives by its values, this may not be the best fit.

avatar
Butternut Box Response
1y
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. We're really sorry to hear that this was your experience working at Butternut. We truly care about our squad and take feedback like this seriously and are striving to create a fair and open environment where everyone feels valued. If you’d be open to sharing more, we'd love to know more about your experience and understand how we can improve. Please reach out to us via people@butternutbox.com

Explore other reviews about Butternut Box

5.0
Jun 15, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I have to say this is the most rewarding workplace I’ve experienced. It is a truly mission-driven culture where our core values drive our daily decisions and product. The environment is incredibly agile and fast-paced, which means you are constantly learning. From a career development standpoint, everything is exceptionally clear and tailored to the individual. Whether you want to progress down an Individual Contributor pathway, or step into a People Management route or try a new challenge through internal mobility - there are clear frameworks and opportunities in place for everyone, On top of that, you get to work alongside some of the brightest, most ego-free, and collaborative people (and passionate animal lovers) in the industry! !!

Cons

My only flag is that the business moves so fast that keeping up with the rapid pace can sometimes feel intense. It requires lots of adaptability and resilience, but having such a supportive team makes it completely worth it.

5.0
Jun 9, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

If you want a career that is both intellectually stimulating and deeply meaningful, this is the place to be! Mission & values driven culture: It’s rare to find a company that actually lives its values every single day. The mission here isn't just a slogan on the wall; it’s the heartbeat of the business. There is a profound, shared commitment to making a positive, tangible impact on the environment, which makes the work incredibly rewarding. Incredible team & collaboration: You will be working alongside some of the brightest, most passionate, and genuinely supportive people. The culture is collaborative, ego-free, and highly motivating. Unmatched development opportunities: Leadership genuinely invests in your growth. Whether you are looking to sharpen your current skillset or take on new leadership challenges, the developmental pathways and mentorship here will fast-track your career.

Cons

The pace is fast and there is a high bar, which means it’s not a place where you can just coast. However, if you love a healthy challenge, you will thrive here.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All