employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer

Engaged Employer

NO NO NO - Liability Adjuster CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer Employee Review

1.0
Jul 16, 2021
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Free classic AAA roadside assistance Decent benefits - HIGH deductible but HSA contributions from the company do help with that. Diversity is welcomed. I met some amazing people while working there.

Cons

I loved CSAA at first, and I was so happy to work there. I used to tell everyone how great it was to work there and how much they cared about their employees. Key word = used to. We got a new CEO (Tom Troy) and everything started going downhill. The pandemic hit and everyone's life got turned upside down. Although I do appreciate the fact that we were able to transition to working remotely so quickly, upper management did not seem to care about the mental wellbeing or sanity of their employees during this change and decided that this was the right time to completely change our job responsibilities, while simultaneously deciding to put us through 1 week of auto physical damage training virtually so we could write our own estimates. Then months later we were put through another week of virtual training, and after that, we were expected to be proficient at writing and reviewing estimates. While we were working from home and struggling to deal with the ongoing pandemic, we were now forced to take FNOLs all day and take calls for claims that were not our own (which were mostly escalated calls because their adjuster was not answering the phone or calling them back), while also working our own claims with our own phone lines blowing up, writing estimates, and settling total losses. We were expected to be in available status all the time on the phone, never mind the fact that in order to get help with writing estimates or settling total losses (which were completely new skills for us), sometimes it could take upwards of an hour to get assistance. Office collaboration was out of the question since we were all working virtually, and it was a lot harder to get help when needed. Despite all the work that was put on our plates, missed calls were unacceptable and we were micro-managed on every little thing. We were told that layoffs would most likely be inevitable in March of 2020, however by September 2020, with the pandemic still raging, CSAA fired a large group of people instead, for reasons that are questionable to say the least. I can't help but wonder if they fired people instead of laying them off in order to fight unemployment claims... nevertheless, top-performing employees who had never even been written up were let go, which quadrupled the workload on those who remained, causing many to take stress-related leave of absences. Upper management and the company as a whole have shown questionable moral conduct and it is apparent that they only look out for themselves. They do not care about us, the "little people." Their lack of compassion and unrealistic expectations have caused a mass amount of adjusters (and supervisors as well) to flee to a different insurance company. There are so many former CSAA employees at this other company that I have dubbed it the new CSAA. Seasoned adjusters who I never thought would leave the company have quit or spontaneously retired, and now, since so many people have left, CSAA has hired "associate adjusters" who I guarantee will be doing the same amount of work for a lot less pay.... which now that I think about it, was probably CSAA's plan all along. During 2020, overtime was strictly FORBIDDEN. If we got stuck on a call after our shift ended (and sometimes FNOL calls can take quite a while), supervisors were advised to tell us to not put overtime on our timecards and that we could take an extra break or longer lunch on a different day to make up for that, which now that I think about it, is probably illegal? Hmmm... It's funny how CSAA fired employees for having "lack of integrity," when in fact it is CSAA itself that suffers from a severe lack of integrity and moral code.

Explore other reviews about CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer

5.0
May 28, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I am grateful for the resources and vendor relationships that Mobilitas provides. They help me work faster and more efficiently as a Commercial Casualty Adjuster. I also appreciate that the company supports the use of AI, which helps make our work easier and more efficient.

Cons

Opportunities for advancement have become more limited over the past year. It feels like there is not a clear or effective path to move into leadership. The current leadership programs do not feel very helpful or are not geared toward claims roles. It can also feel like staying in the same position for a long time before being seriously considered for promotion.

1.0
Jul 4, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

- High level of job autonomy, enabling ownership and independent decision-making. - Clear direction and strong guidance from direct leadership, supporting alignment and goal achievement. - Manageable workload with appropriate funding and resources to effectively meet objectives.

Cons

- Misaligned priorities between IT leadership and executive leadership, creating confusion and slowing decision-making. - Organizational dysfunction and lack of coordination among leadership teams, impacting execution and accountability. - Perceived favoritism and inequitable opportunities, affecting morale, trust, and employee engagement.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All