Frustratingly Little Opportunity for Advancement - Associate Director College Board Employee Review

2.0
Jan 24, 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Driven by an enduring mission to ensure more kids across America succeed in high school and matriculate to college, College Board fosters close-knit teams. Middle-management — Executive Directors, Vice Presidents — is generally supportive of personal and professional goals.

Cons

College Board leadership seems to have a poor understanding of the labor market, specifically the detestable “market rates” for salary. While a not-for-profit, the organization apparently limits itself to similarly large non-profits to determine compensation, even though talent is leaving for very different types of firms and organizations. Leadership should reconsider, that is broaden, its basket of comparable organizations to retain talent in the current market. Additionally, the idea that successful, high-performing individuals must “wait their turn” for promotion is frustrating and severely diminishes the talent experience. Though direct-managers' hands are often tied by anachronistic HR practices, like a queueing system within teams for promotions — i.e., regardless of growth or impact one cannot advance ahead of others on their team who have “waited their turn." This runs orthogonal to stated goals about advancement. Advancement should be predicated on impact, not tenure of service. This fact played a substantial role in me leaving the organization, in addition to the depressed pay for the value I brought (including in-demand technical skills).

avatar
College Board Response
2y
Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback on working at College Board. The mission orientation of the people on our teams unites us and drives us to continue growing in how we serve students. We are sorry to hear that we did not meet your career advancement expectations. We offer a competitive total rewards program (salary, incentives, and benefits) that seeks to retain and attract top talent, compete with the external market, and ensure fair and consistent pay practices. We are proud of our data-driven approach to both compensation and promotions and are doing more to share the opportunities with our employees.

Explore other reviews about College Board

5.0
Jun 7, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

- Fantastic Management - Clear Goals - Good teamwork

Cons

- The work is a little soul sucking

4.0
Jun 10, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Strong mission and meaningful work Talented, dedicated colleagues Opportunities to work on large-scale, high-impact projects Exposure to complex programs and cross-functional collaboration Opportunity to build strong project management, operations, and stakeholder management skills Benefits

Cons

Employee experience can vary significantly depending on team and leadership Communication and decision-making are not always transparent Expectations can sometimes be unclear or shift without enough context Change management could be stronger

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All