Senior Internal Auditor - Anonymous employee Commerce Bank Employee Review

1.0
Jan 5, 2018
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

It is easy to get a job here, please see the cons section for more details.

Cons

Does a great deal of micromanagement. Your manager wants to be CC'ed on everything, all the workpapers need have a great deal of unnecessary detail like where did the supporting documentation came from, when, how, the purpose of the document, how does it relate to the audit objective, highlights, tickmark explanations etc. If you forgot a tickmark, tickmark explanation, or explanation was not detailed enough, all hell will brake lose. All the objectives in the audit are budgeted. If you are over budget even by an hour you get penalized for it. There is a review/evaluation at the end of every audit, to show how bad of job you have done. The review mainly points out your negative traits and never anything positive. Everybody is after the bonus (5-10%) so everybody blames each other. They expect you to know everything – all the bank databases (which there are a lot), all the business units, the audit objectives, people you’ll be working with, business unit polices and procedure and process etc. If you are unsure about something and you ask a question, you’ll get a bad review in your evaluation because you wasted your senior’s time (i.e. Evaluation will read something like: lack of understanding of the business unit) You never get any growth opportunities, when the time comes for a promotion or salary increase, they will evaluate you from all your audit evaluations (which only points out the negatives). Long story short, I was there for 2.5 years and I hated every moment. The salary was $56,000, 20% lower than what I make right now, doing 35% less work.

avatar
Commerce Bank Response
7y
We are sorry to see you were unhappy in your employment with Commerce. Documentation and metrics are a part of any audit job, but micromanaging is not. Unfortunately, there are times when our managers must take extra care to work with employees to improve their performance and in some cases, there just isn’t a fit. Our audit department has higher than average engagement scores, so we are happy to report this is not often the case. We appreciate your feedback and we hope you have found a great fit with your new employer.

Explore other reviews about Commerce Bank

5.0
Jun 5, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great people. Interesting work. Great work balance.

Cons

I honestly cannot think of anything.

1.0
Jun 25, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

None - the pay was well below what I was used to making.

Cons

You can include that if it’s true, but it’s safest to present it as your personal experience rather than implying a medical conclusion or making broader claims about the company. Here’s a revised version: Commerce Bank was the worst place I’ve ever worked. I came into the role with years of experience, confidence, and a strong work ethic, but I left questioning my abilities in a way I never had before. The management style I experienced was disparaging, overly critical, and unsupportive. Rather than feeling coached or developed, I felt constantly torn down. The work environment became so toxic for me that I ultimately sought therapy to cope with the anxiety I experienced surrounding work. My anxiety became severe enough that my healthcare provider increased my medication. No job should have that kind of impact on someone’s mental well-being. I recognize that others may have different experiences, but mine was one of the most damaging professional experiences of my career. I would encourage prospective employees to carefully evaluate the leadership and management culture before accepting a position, as it can make all the difference. This version clearly states your personal experience (“for me,” “I experienced”) without asserting that the company universally causes those outcomes. That makes the review both compelling and more defensible.

1
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All