Pros
The company really takes care of you. Medical, eye, dental, and life insurance is cheap because GAIG covers the majority of the cost. They match you're 401k contribution 100% up to 4.5%. Weight room is only $50 a year. Insurance, 401k, and parking are all tax deductible. Weight room, employee stock purchase program, and group term life are not, but they offer you AFG stock and a 15% discount. Also, disability is 60% of your income. Very secure company for you and as a business they are very conservative. Not risky position what so ever. The company performs very well.
Cons
Find the right position. The job I have requires me to sit at a desk and stare at a computer all day, mostly in isolation. I do not believe sitting at a desk all day and staring at a computer is healthy for your body and your mind. Many people feel it to be okay and that is fine but if you get a chance to take a job that allows you to speak to people, build relationships, and gives you a variable schedule, I would take it over a position behind a desk.