Full service shopper - Anonymous employee Instacart Employee Review

2.0
Apr 22, 2018
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Flexibility, working on your own

Cons

I've only just started working about a month ago so I'll change this review if needed but currently my thoughts are this : they are not a people / customer oriented company. They pressure you to be faster, which I get it - speed and delivering to the customer quickly is a great thing - but they take it too far. First off, 90% of the time they send me to a store location that is not the closest one to the customer & you don't find that out until after you've already checked out of the store. That leads to the second off, there tends to be a lot of items that the store location might not carry and if you would have sent me to the location closest to the customer then that location probably would have had their items because when a customer is ordering their stuff through the app they are thinking about the location that they usually shop at which tends to be the one closest to them. Also when I'm picking a replacement I like to send the customer a message to ask them what they would prefer and talk to them about it and that makes my speed go down and it makes me look bad. I get all great reviews for my customer because I talk to them throughout all of it but instacart thinks I'm not so great because my speed goes down. So unnecessary pressure. And now, I've just checked my earnings adding today's rates + per item of the order I just did and I was underpaid. If you add in my tip, I'm not underpaid but the tip isn't suppose to count, that's extra money for me, not for you to pay me with. At the end of every shift they give you an opportunity to provide feedback and it's like I'm talking to a computer because they do not communicate with you at all they'll send messages but you can't reply to them and when I put something in the feedback I don't get an email back or anything telling me "Oh hey Samantha I read your feedback and this is what happened", nope I get silence. They should strive to be there for their employees and to be more customer oriented. Speed is great but accuracy and the customers satisfaction is what should be top priority. Then don't even get me started on hours. In order to get first dibs on hours you have to work 90 hours within 3 weeks so average 30 hours a week or 25 weekend hours over 3 weeks, which I only have time for about 15 a week so I have to wait to pick my hours and by the time I get to pick my hours there's hardly anything so I get more like 5 a week which I don't appreciate. I understand letting people who work more get to pick their hours first but why does it have to be from Sunday to Wednesday why can't it the people who work more get to pick Sunday and the people who work less get to pick Monday and why does it have to be so many hours to meet the requirement to get to pick on Sunday I want to work 15 hours but you're not even giving me the opportunity to work 15 hours.

Explore other reviews about Instacart

5.0
Mar 29, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great gig that can be done on flexible hours.

Cons

Gas prices having been go up.

2.0
Jun 21, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Fun going out and talking to people. You will interact with people everyday. You control how much you get paid. Lots of flexibility in the time between accepting an order and traveling to the store and beginning to shop. It isn't pedal to the metal to get to the store like DoorDash is. You can also cancel batches after accepting as long as you keep your rate under 15%. This is different from DoorDash where your rankings will suffer if g.t. 2% cancellation rate.

Cons

There's a learning curve and it takes a while to learn each chain of stores' items. Once you become proficient at one store, the algorithm will lowball your offers relative to other less-experienced Instacart shoppers. Overall, Instacart shoppers likely get paid similar or less than the store's regular employees.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All