Height of dysfunction - Anonymous employee J. Jill Employee Review

1.0
Aug 23, 2012
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

There are some great people who work for the company and try to keep the motors running. If it wasn't for people below the Director level the company would crumble.

Cons

I have never seen a company run so poorly. One woman, Paula Bennett the President, makes all decisions. Everyone else is given the illusion of decision making ability, but then Paula swoops in and casts her decision without considering the hours of work and discussions that have already taken place. Working here is completely frustrating. The bonuses that are worked into the Sr. level and above's contracts would infuriate the other 95% of the company if they ever knew. Company does poorly, gets sold and the executive team takes home a years salary as a bonus. What did everyone else get? Nothing. Upper management has been completely replaced as they started growing their legs and questioning the actions of Paula. Once they started being a squeaky wheel, they were fired. All in all, an utterly awful place to work and I caution EVERYONE to stay away from here. It will affect your personal life, your confidence and you will hate coming to the office everyday.

Explore other reviews about J. Jill

5.0
Sep 13, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Friendly staff, schedule vacation easily

Cons

Standing for long periods of time

1.0
Apr 1, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Extremely Hard to think of one singular Pro

Cons

Working at J.Jill was one of the most disappointing professional experiences I have had, largely because of poor management and an unhealthy company culture. Management was disorganized, inconsistent, and frequently unprofessional. Expectations changed constantly with little to no communication, leaving employees set up to fail. There was no clear direction, no transparency, and very little accountability from leadership. Instead of addressing problems, management often shifted blame onto employees. The environment felt toxic and political. Employees were not treated with respect, and hard work was rarely recognized or rewarded. Strong employees were expected to take on more and more responsibility without additional compensation, support, or advancement. At the same time, favoritism and poor leadership decisions created frustration across the team. Communication from management was consistently poor. Decisions were made behind closed doors, information was withheld, and employees were often left scrambling because leadership failed to plan ahead. Rather than supporting their teams, management created unnecessary stress and made an already difficult environment worse. Morale was extremely low, and it was obvious why turnover was so high. Many employees felt undervalued, ignored, and disposable. The company talks about caring about its people, but in practice there was very little support, appreciation, or investment in employees. J.Jills Merch team has serious issues with management and culture that need to be addressed. Until leadership becomes more competent, transparent, and respectful, I would not recommend the company to anyone looking for a supportive or well-run workplace.

3
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All