Great Potential but very hard to achieve success - Construction Superintendent M/I Homes Employee Review

3.0
Mar 27, 2017
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good earning potential on paper Business seems to be growing Base pay seems higher than other companies for similar positions

Cons

Workload very heavy Focused on customer survey responses and if not 100% unable to achieve bonus All departments impact one another so if one leaves a bad impression you can bust your butt and get nothing Management suport lacking Vendors are overworked and lack of quality workmanship with no accountability They say customer ratification is #1 and don't deliver unless ready but when it comes down to it you are going to deliver especially if end of month, quarter and especially year. When it comes down to it closings are more important than customer satisfaction.

Explore other reviews about M/I Homes

5.0
Feb 23, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I gained so much knowledge and skills.

Cons

Lots of traveling, wear and tear on the personal vehicle.

1.0
Mar 21, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Earning potential was great, benefits were decent.

Cons

An incredibly toxic work environment defined by micromanagement, constantly shifting and unrealistic sales goals, and a leadership team that often operated more like enforcers than mentors. Targets were routinely increased at the end of each quarter, effectively stripping salespeople of earned bonuses and eroding trust. The culture leaned heavily on intimidation and public pressure. Sales meetings often felt more like performance critiques than coaching, and required role-playing exercises were frequently uncomfortable and unnecessary. There was a consistent pattern of favoritism, where poor behavior was overlooked for some while others were held to entirely different standards. Management’s approach to motivation relied too heavily on guilt and financial pressure, with paid time off subtly discouraged and income used as leverage rather than support. Collaboration was undermined by leadership creating internal competition in ways that felt divisive rather than productive. There were also multiple instances of inappropriate and racially insensitive remarks made in group settings, which further contributed to an unprofessional and uncomfortable environment. Overall, while the role had potential, the culture and leadership practices made it difficult to succeed or feel respected.

1
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All