If the customer is always right, are the employee's always wrong? - Commission Sales Associate Macy's Employee Review

1.0
Oct 29, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Flexible Scheduling - If you were scheduled a shift that you can't work, you can advertise your shift but you have to do it right away so other associates who want to pick-up hours can take that shift and you'll be clear of that shift and you can keep your points. You're also able to pick up shifts if you want/need more hours. You're paid weekly which is a MAJOR plus. You encounter a wide range of personalities, you're bound to make a friend or two along the way.

Cons

PAY: Macy's boasts competitive wages. Who is their competitor, Panhandlers? Macy's pays about $20,000 less than MOST other companies. As a commission based sales associate you earn what is called a draw. Basically, you have to sell about $200.00 worth of product an hour in order to earn your 8% commission which at most, equal's out to another dollar per hour. However, this goal is unreasonable when there are 8 people on the selling floor and no customers. You get a 20% "back door" discount, meaning you receive your discount on the back of the house AFTER you've made your purchase. It is then loaded back onto your card where you can ONLY spend said discount at Macy's. You do back breaking work for little pay. Up and down stairs, lifting and puling heavy boxes. On your feet ALL DAY. WORK ENVIRONMENT: Managers have no respect for any of their employees (granted this is probably due to the lack of respect they receive from their over lord bosses, but nonetheless; unnecessary) they have you come in on your off days around the holidays. You can't use PTO during the whole month of December and most of November. Managers will manipulate and lie in the face of an employee just to get them to do what they want them to do. They also use questionable tactics in order to bait employees (basically, if they were cops; you'd be able to claim entrapment and win) Upper management and HR are a bunch of tyrants and refuse to listen to any of the lower level employees. Overall Macy's is cesspool for sexism and racism. If you're not "one of the boys" or your manager is African American and you're not OR vice a versa you're SOL. Their Gestapo loss prevention or (LP) is a joke. They worry more about employee theft (which is less likely) than actual large scale shop lifters. LP is mostly young kids and most, if not all, are of minority descent. Why is this a problem you ask? Because LP poses as undercover shoppers; some pretending to be thieves. Apparently, only African Americans and Hispanic people steal. (Side eye) Food Service Staff is almost ALL African American. Macy's allows them to make your meals but doesn't allow them to sell your fine jewelry. Thanks for setting civil rights back about 50 years.

Explore other reviews about Macy's

5.0
Mar 24, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good benefits, flexible scheduling, good time off

Cons

Limited time of during holidays, key days

avatar
Macy's Response
3mo
We appreciate you sharing your feedback about your time as an At Your Service Associate! Thank you!
3.0
Oct 10, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

1) Flexible Scheduling - If you were scheduled a shift that you can't do (drops down 3 or 4 weeks of work schedule), you can advertise your shift but you have to do it right away so other associates that wants to pick-up hours can take that shift and you'll be clear of that shift. I say do it ASAP because if you do it later then nobody would want to pick up a last minute shift 2) Pick-up shifts - Okay listen carefully! Shifts drops down EVERY friday but the picking up is Saturday. The executive office will tell you that you're allowed to start picking up Sunday morning. From experience and other associates telling me, you can start picking up Saturday at 7am SHARP. Be ready at 6:59am. Open/available shifts comes from the office (due to big sale events, they need more than usual associates working) AND from full time associates. They get their schedule AND advertise/pick-up shifts on the same day. So they get to advertise their shifts early bird style. 3) Part-time Options - There are 5 different types of part-time option: Option 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5. I'm not really familiar with Option 1 or 2. Option 5 gets 3-8 hours, Option 4 gets 12-20 hours, Option 1 and maybe 2 are full time which gets 32-38 hours. NOTE: The minimum to maximum hours for each option will be the scheduled shifts. The only way for you to get MORE hours is when you pick up later on. AND during the holidays of course. For example: As an option 5 you'll be scheduled 5 hours. When its time to pick up you, picked up, let's say, 9:45am-1:45pm (4 hours). So add that to your scheduled hours for that week, you have 9 hours. It's not a lot but thats why you gotta be a pro at picking up shifts. Holidays will do you good. 4) Pay Frequency - Weekly! 5) Associates/Co-workers - You will meet friends along the way. You'll see the good and the bad. You'll see who you get along with, stick with them. And stay away from those ones with nasty attitude. 6) Good for people starting out in retail. You will really learn a lot. 7) More hours Opportunity - I'm not really sure if this falls under pros or cons but I'll mention this anyway. Sometimes the store will be short on associates (called out, left early, etc.) and the managers will ask their associates on the floor if they would like to stay until a certain time. I said I wasn't sure if this was good or bad only because some people like the extra hours AND some probably already worked a long day and they don't want to stay any longer for that day. Oh and some has plans after their shift. Sometimes though it gets annoying, people just wanna go home and rest you know. 8) Associate Discount - it's okay. It has its perks

Cons

1) Minimum wage. You'll probably get a small raise later maybe a year or two. But it's not much of a raise, a couple cents. 2) "Sales Associate" - You pretty much do everything. You ring on the register, do returns, check fitting rooms, put back clothes. There are some days when you're the only one working in one department and it's not busy at all, and you'd go to the fitting rooms to check. I swear everytime I leave the service desk to do that, a customer will always show up when I'm not there. Really?? When you get out of the fitting room you see them and you have to run to them before they get impatient and leave. 3) Catty associates - The full time associates that have been working there for ages (literally like 20 years or something) are very very protective and competitive over their sales goal. If there is a full time and a part time scheduled for one department (1 service desk with 2 registers maybe) you sure as hell bet that the full time will stay and hog the register while you have to put stuff back. My advice: Don't let them step all over you! They have goals to make, but so do you! If they ever tell you that they have to make their sales goal because they're full time, tell them that you do too! It's not always like this with every single associate. With the people I worked and got along with we took turns because we know how competitive ringing goes around. We helped each other out. I hope the same goes for you. 4) Opening a credit - As a Macy's Retail Sales Associate, you are required to open credits - which is part of the job so it's fine. BUT the part that is not fine is when the managers constantly remind and tell you to open credits as they walk around the store and they see you. It's okay to tell me once or twice about it but it's NOT okay when you shove it down my throat. I know I have to get credits but you don't have to tell me like I'm deaf or disabled. Managers can sometimes make you feel like you're not trying your best with opening it, in other words, incompetent. It has great incentives, don't get me wrong. But please, ease on with the nagging. We're trying our best but not everyone wants to open one for reasons such as: bad credit, closed macys card to decrease payments/interest fee, not interested in opening one at all! 5) Department assignment - Be careful on which departments you pick up when you try to get hours. Other departments are the best but some are just so boring and dead. My only advice is to keep yourself busy even if it's something you don't want to do. At least you're doing something. 6) For people who wants to gain retail experience and some cash, this is the place for you. BUT if you want to make this your career, there's no future here for you. Some associates (mostly full time) have been here for the longest time and this is the only job for them, so just understand when they get too competitive or catty with ringing people out - that's pretty much their life. 7) Easily burn out! - Take a day off or two, you will need it. Bottom line: Every company/employer has its pros and cons, but don't be discouraged. A good work experience is great for future jobs. Remember, work is work. You can't be picky. Overall, Macy's is alright.

334
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All