Do not work in HR! - Human Resources Morningstar Employee Review

1.0
Apr 4, 2021
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

flexible PTO policy, sabbatical every 4 years

Cons

Human Resource is upper management is a mess, and I say this with my deepest sincerity. Morningstar continues to hire "upper management" from within the organization with limited applicable experience for the roles they are filling. They say they are "hiring from within" because it builds better understanding of the business but in actuality most of the untalented management is thrust into power due to close friendships with HR leadership. Middle management and individual contributors are not compensated appropriately AND to add to that, work long tiring hours for department heads who don't understand up from down. There continues to be a mass exodus from HR, leaving only the underqualified in charge. Instead of paying team members who have actual HR expertise or any intrinsic drive a fair salary, they hire external contractors and pay double $$ - I have personally witnessed this time and time again, and am BAFFLED that the CEO has not recognized the leak in talent stemming directly from mismanaged teams in HR. Don't let my review of HR dissuade you from working for other area's in the company - area's outside of HR have a completely different culture and different senior leadership. However, if you are looking to work in HR, think long and hard before coming here - you won't be able to make a change until senior management is managed out. HR does monitor these postings so you can be sure that they will respond with a wordy explanation negating my comments. But as a former colleague, I can tell you - if they had an option to leave, they would.

avatar
Morningstar Response
5y
I am sorry to read your review and hear that you had a poor experience in our Talent & Culture group. Your feedback while concerning also gives us a chance to share more insight into how we have grown and our plans to continue building a modern HR function. First, as part of our culture and career development track we always look to promote talented colleagues into new roles or leadership positions. Our team benefits from the knowledge in conjunction with early career talent and valued consultants and industry partnerships. In 2021, we are strategically transforming our function to be prepared to meet the demands of our growing business, workforce and more importantly continue to create the kind of culture that is welcoming and supportive of all people. We are also working hard to focus on adding more colleagues to the high-growth areas of our company, and that is especially true in Talent & Culture where we believe there is room for many to join us across our key experience areas. As you may know, Morningstar has been through extraordinary, fast-paced growth not making it always easy to navigate especially for colleagues in roles who are supporting acquisitions and a large, global workforce. We’re sorry your experience fell short. If you want to share any feedback, we’d appreciate the chance to follow up with you and we wish you the very best in your future aspirations. ~Bevin Desmond, Head of Talent & Culture (CHRO)

Explore other reviews about Morningstar

5.0
Jul 13, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

good company work life balance

Cons

really no cons for the firm

4.0
Jul 14, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Very good culture and a healthy env to work at

Cons

The pay is below average compared to the market

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All