Great to Start, Gets Stale Later - Underwriter Travelers Employee Review

3.0
Aug 20, 2019
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good benefits, good PTO, etc. Great place to start a career, especially in the UPDP pipeline programs....specialty lines are particularly good and are known across the industry as some of the best. While trivial at face value, some of the newer initiatives (Dress for Your Day, etc) are actually nice perks. The customer centric "value add" model is nice to buy into vs just price and terms. Specialty lines are arguably the value leaders of their respective markets. BU management wants to win and drives hard to put initiatives in place to do so. It can be a lot, but there are lots of tools to bring to market to differentiate.

Cons

Elephant in the room: TRV is known for the "Travelers Discount", paying employees up to 20% below market and brag about it in leadership meetings. BU leadership wonders why people leave yet will jawbone ceaselessly about "employee engagement & retention" while doing absolutely nothing differently or adjusting comp to close the gap. The running joke amongst the rank-and-file is the only way to make more is to leverage an offer from a competitor. The comp process is a joke and a black box nobody can figure out up to the Sr. VP level. It's been a "tough comp year" with "the bonus pool is down" for the last decade despite management locally and c-suite both telling employees how good of a job we're doing and how TRV earnings are good. The messaging is completely different public vs. mid-Feb and while management is blissfully ignorant of that fact the little people grumble amongst themselves. Nobody can figure out how to quantify how performance translates to bonus; the inputs are extremely fluffy and left to local management's discretion...asking management direct questions just gets platitudes and redirection. Each experienced person that leaves a BU is essentially replaced by a new hire trainee, fewer and fewer experienced people are remaining in specialty BUs and more and more relationships with customers and agents are held at the executive levels making lower level people administrators of the business which is disheartening. The company will say things like "we have a great pipeline and good continuity" but scramble when someone senior leaves and take MONTHS to fill a customer facing executive or management role, even for a planned retirement. Experienced people are told they're "in the continuity plan" but nothing happens when the position opens and the people who were told they were in line for the next step suddenly are not. Our own customers have shared at conferences how they pipeline and identify talent for management and TRV has taken zero from that. The hiring process is atrocious and should be completely revamped. Entry level or experienced people both suffer the months-long delays, bureaucracy, ghosting, "it's with HR I need to wait for them" excuses. RVP and CUO level managers all hate the process; the stories of how screwed up things get are unbelievable for a company this big.

Explore other reviews about Travelers

5.0
Jun 22, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

great salary, many opportunities for growth.

Cons

challenging. will require a lot of learning of the systems.

2.0
Jun 26, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

We receive continuous training to stay up to date with new state regulations and market trends. My colleagues make the day go by quickly. The benefits are very reasonable. There is room for career growth if you know how to network. I appreciate their consistent push for community volunteer opportunities.

Cons

The personal lines department seems to be falling apart right now. Issues with the internal systems are resulting in underwriters doing multiple jobs and becoming a dumping ground for all agent issues even if they aren't underwriting related. I don't feel that the directors are truly expressing to the senior leadership team the impact that all these issues are having on the mental health and quality of life for the employees that are on the front lines trying to maintain a good reputation for the company. It's sad to see how quickly this department has gone downhill and the amount of quality underwriters that are jumping ship for different departments or different companies all together. What's even sadder it that no one with authority seems to care, or listen, when concerns are brought forth. I truly advise anyone considering applying for any position within the personal insurance department to hold off until things start to change - it's not worth the mental anguish that you'll experience.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All