ICW Group reviews

3.4

53% would recommend to a friend

(56 total reviews)

Kevin Prior

81% approve of CEO

56% positive business outlook

Reviews by job title

56 reviews

Reviews about "Compensation"

Return to all reviews
1.0
Jul 24, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

* The colleagues are genuinely the best part of working here. There are talented, hardworking people who care about doing the right thing and supporting one another. * The work itself can be interesting, and there is a great deal of potential if leadership were willing to listen to the people.

Cons

* This organization has changed dramatically, and unfortunately not for the better. Morale is at an all-time low, and it’s difficult to find employees who are genuinely engaged or optimistic about the future. * Procurement and Vendor Management leadership has become one of the biggest disappointments. Decisions are often made without consulting the teams responsible for executing them, and employees feel their expertise and feedback are not even considered. * Leadership frequently over-engineers simple processes, creating unnecessary bureaucracy that slows work down instead of improving it. * Communication lacks transparency, and commitments made to employees are too often changed or forgotten, resulting in a significant loss of trust. Employees are not even consulted when considering major department changes affecting them. And communication to employees has become sloppy. At times, there is no communication at all for something that might impact employees, leaving them guessing or requesting updates. * Compensation is below market, yet employees are repeatedly told that the company’s culture makes up for the pay gap. Unfortunately, culture does not pay bills, and even cost-of-living adjustments have been overlooked while expectations continue to increase. * Smaller teams are burnt out and make to do a lot more with less resources resulting in most employees feeling stressed all the time. * The company invests heavily in leadership development, but there is little evidence that those investments are translating into better leaders. In many cases, leadership effectiveness appears to have declined rather than improved. * Many employees stay because they need a paycheck, not because they believe in the direction of the organization or feel valued.

5.0
Jun 12, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

1. Management is invested in professional development and are focused on growth opportunities within the company. 2. Case load is manageable and allows for a reasonable work/life balance. 3. Compensation in terms of salary, paid time off, insurance, etc. is very fair.

Cons

Nothing- None at this time.

1.0
May 15, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I received a 20% increase in pay when making a lateral move to this company in a remote position, however it's true when they say that "money can't buy happiness" and if it's "too good to be true, it probably is"!

Cons

As an experienced professional with almost two decades of experience and being considered a high performer with many wonderful development opportunities in my prior roles, I was specifically recruited to ICW Group to help them build out new a new capability. I joined the company with expertise and enthusiasm, ready to make an impact, but quickly realized that there was actually no senior leader commitment to the subject matter I'd been hired to create. I spent the next two years working to build a case for executing on the capabilities I'd been hired to design and charged with pitching it to leadership to obtain buy-in with the hope of keeping my job. During the course of those two years, my leader wrote complimentary performance reviews on my behalf, gave me a merit raise each year and also elected to give me an annual leader directed bonus of 15 percent. A little more than two years into the position, it was determined that the company was in fact NOT going to execute on the capability they specifically hired me to design and I was asked to shift my work to help a colleague with their workload. I continued reporting to the same manager who had previously been very complimentary of my work. Over the course of the next 3-4 months, the manager and I met weekly (as we always had previously) and as a remote worker, I shared my screen and we chatted about what I was working on and they seemed happy with my progress. Then one day, a switch flipped and they no longer approved of the work they'd previously been directing me to complete and praising me for. All of a sudden, I was a targeted problem in their eyes and the verbal and written communications received from my leader were not only demeaning, but hurtful. Within a few weeks of their attitude towards me changing and without ever being placed on a performance improvement plan, I was fired. During their single sentence to me before HR jumped on the call, my leader told me that I was "not qualified" to do my job (which was not true). The date of my termination was merely a week or two before I was set to be paid my annual bonus, which I obviously didn’t receive. The whole experience felt very surreal and betraying - especially because what I do is very niche focused and there aren't many roles in this specific space. I had been very happy and successful at my prior employer and would have never made a change to ICW Group if I hadn't been lured there with the promise of the opportunity to create something I was passionate about. I not only wouldn't recommend to a friend, but also wouldn't recommend this company to an enemy either! It's also worth noting that within a few months of joining the company, ICW Group laid off literally their entire commercial package underwriting team. The lay-off followed their failed attempt at expanding from a monoline workers compensation writer into the commercial package marketplace due to a lack of strategy, poor products and senior leaders with significant aversion to risk. I later discovered that following these employee terminations, ICW Group was found guilty of violating the National Labor Relations Act by essentially adding a gag order to their severance agreement (search CA Case 21-CA-329099 for more detail), keeping the fired staff from being able to exercise their right to freedom of speech and share the details of their separation from the company. If you are considering joining this company, think very hard first and be sure to ask the right questions. Ask about their strategy, employee turnover, empowerment, transparency and culture. I wish I'd dug deeper before making the leap to ICW Group because it was truly the worst employee experience of my life.

Viewing 1 - 3 of 56 Reviews

Glassdoor has 297 ICW Group reviews submitted anonymously by ICW Group employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if ICW Group is right for you.