Amica Insurance reviews

3.9

74% would recommend to a friend

(1,021 total reviews)
avatar

Edmund (Ted) Shallcross III

81% approve of CEO

74% positive business outlook

Amica Insurance has an employee rating of 3.9 out of 5 stars, based on 1,021 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Amica Insurance employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

1K reviews
2.0
Jul 6, 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

- Good job for someone coming out of college. Absolutely can help you vault into a better position at another company. - When you're not micromanaged and can be somewhat in control of what you do, there are some good resources to help you do your job properly. - The benefits are very solid overall, despite the elimination of the pension plan. - Generally speaking, the people you work with really do care about your well being. I think the "Family" environment is a toxic phrase, but you will grow close to your coworkers if you are a generally social and friendly person.

Cons

- Due to not providing work from home systems to employees, alongside other random issues with vendors or just the remote connection itself, this job is not going to move towards permanent work from home at any point. This is in part because Amica does not want to encourage that to happen. In truth, they are ill-prepared to do so between manager availability and general investment in work-from-home technology, but they also do not want to lose control of their micromanaging capabilities. - Of note, during the beginning of the pandemic, employees were initially forced to buy their own computers to work from home, with a small reimbursement that came later. I actually helped a few people to purchase computers because they did not have one at home, and did not know what to pick. Most people were picking low cost computers that would not be able to support a stable work environment. What does that say about Amica wanting to prioritize its customers? - When I started, the environment was not a call center. It has rapidly deteriorated into being just that, and an understaffed one at that. They send out emails happily talking about the people that are coming on board, but I frequently see that being offset by experienced representatives leaving or being let go. My office has a lot of longtime employees that say they are only still there because they have the pension plan still locked in. Amica won't keep people for as long without this benefit in place. - Longtime representatives have been forced to help out with regular call assistance, instead of the company wanting to utilize their expertise with more important matters. Why should someone who has been with the company 25-30 years be taking a billing call? That's just absurd. Even some of the trainers have helped with general call assistance. My last company had two full-time trainers that just worked on material development and training. We would have much more educated employees if they were allowed to do their job like that. We regionalized our call centers out of sheer desperation, and the actual training was so limited, and we were untested on our knowledge until well after the original training. Despite having previously taken calls in all of these states at my last job, I still feel ill-prepared on a lot of things, and I genuinely believe I am better at my job than the job has been making me feel lately. - Even the longtime managers have had moments of getting fed up lately. However, there have been many instances where I've brought up a concern, and it's been Amica "Koolaided" away until I actually force them to admit that they agree with my concerns. - Progressing up the chain is very limited unless you meet life referral goals. I only got a promotion due to a fantastic review by my manager on my behalf, and I will be eternally grateful to them for that. But even though sales goals are not emphasized during the interview process (at least during mine they weren't), you will rapidly get sucked into the necessity of meeting those goals if you want to make more money. I have more concerns but that's all I feel like typing up right now, and I think it's concerning enough.

avatar
Amica Insurance Response
3y
Thank you for taking the time to write this review and feedback. We understand that you may not think it will make any difference, however we agree that your comments are concerning and we’d like you to know that we truly do listen to our employees, so we would welcome the opportunity to speak with you. The feedback we’ve received from our employees has already helped us make changes to our work-from-home program, and some positions here are now currently fully remote. If you’re ever interested in getting in touch with us to share more about your experience, you can email us at employeefeedback@amica.com. Thank you again.
1.0
Mar 18, 2022

Find something else

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Benefits, though if you look you can find other companies with equal or better now. Being able to work from 2 days out of the week.

Cons

Where to start…Company states that customer service is their reason why they have succeeded for so long. And while that may be true, they have changed on what they are expecting out of employees. They want you to provide exceptional customer service but the all they really care about are numbers. You can be the best customer service representative but if you are not hitting your numbers your are often overlooked. And yes, I do get that getting more business is what keeps any company going but do not say that “because of our customer service, we are able to strive through hard times” when all they really care about are numbers. Next is the software that they use. I could not tell you when something runs smoothly so that you can do your job. I have been there for 6+ years now and have seen so many different changes in software that they are using. The most recent update that was done made everything run so slow to the point where we had to tell customers that we will call them back. It has gotten a little better but still running into issues. Depending on the office, managers seems to play favorites. Often small things that people do well are overlooked because someone else might hit their numbers. Receiving recognition will vary depending on your manager which also plays in to on if your are not on their list of what a “good” employee is, you will get overlooked for a deserved promotion. Their promotion is basically a different title, more work, and a bump in pay. They are finally adapting to more work from home days, 2 work from home, 3 days in the office but i feel that the only reason why they made that change is because they are not able to higher anyone and other companies realize that you can still be successful and have responsible workers do their job from home. Because so many people have left the company by either quitting due to finding a new Job or retiring, the work load is starting to take a toll on employees. We are expected to take 20+ Calls through out the day (which is not that hard) still keep up with our activity (follow ups for new business, closings, etc…) and now increasing the amount of states that we have to service with the same pay. This may be a rant or even venting but I used to enjoy working for Amica for the first couple of years. Now it is so stressful that it is affecting my every day life for me and my family.

avatar
Amica Insurance Response
4y
We appreciate you taking the time to share this feedback about your experience at Amica. Please know that we’re always listening, and that without our employees and the comments they share with us, we would not be able to continue to make Amica a great place to work. Because of this, we’d like to learn more about some of the concerns you have when it comes to our software and the management you mentioned in your review. Could you please email us at employeefeedback@amica.com so we can get in touch? Thank you.
2.0
Nov 15, 2016
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good starting pay for part-time employees ( I started part-time) Blue-collar employees are good people and are a "family" A lot of paid holidays Bonus check at years end Good 401k investors On site cafeteria with good prices

Cons

Limited to 4 sick days a YEAR unless you use FMLA (otherwise it is counted against you at year end for pay) White-collar employees see themselves as "better" than the blue-collar employees Management sees you as a number not a person or employee. WAY to many middle/lower management compared to actual workers Double talk is their thing here. They will tell you one thing and do another. They do not hire local, they hire from India for tech because its cheaper. Cliques run this company and would rather have a silent employee than a employee that speaks up. Undervalued salaries unless you are in CORE business (ie: accounting, management, T&D, anyone in 100 building, SOME insurance agents.)

Viewing 34 - 36 of 1,021 Reviews

Glassdoor has 1,071 Amica Insurance reviews submitted anonymously by Amica Insurance employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Amica Insurance is right for you.