Amica Insurance reviews

3.9

74% would recommend to a friend

(1,021 total reviews)
avatar

Edmund (Ted) Shallcross III

81% approve of CEO

74% positive business outlook

Amica Insurance has an employee rating of 3.9 out of 5 stars, based on 1,021 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Amica Insurance employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

1K reviews
1.0
Nov 23, 2021
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

-You work with some decent people at the local level -Full time job with average benefits

Cons

-To say Amica is not adequately staffed is an understatement. The amount of people who are quitting on a weekly basis is staggering. This is not just in the service department. The claims department is losing people left and right and many are retiring early. This in turn creates a massive backlog of work for the current reps. I sincerely believe Amica is reaching an inflection point here and there is a real possibility they won’t be able to weather this storm. Upper management refuses to listen to feedback and keeps doubling down on bad decisions (see the reviews the last 6 months). People are NOT quitting due to the “great resignation”….they are quitting due to too many changes implemented at once and the insane stress level. -Pay is below industry standard -Micromanaged every second of every day -Horrible morale. So much so that the company had to offer a “retention bonus” (that name alone is insulting) for employees who don’t quit before 12/1/2021. What kind of message does that send to the employees?

avatar
Amica Insurance Response
4y
Thank you for your review. We understand that because of staffing, workload has become an issue for some of our employees. We know that our employees are our greatest asset, and we’re working hard to ensure that Amica remains one of the best places to work.
2.0
Aug 26, 2021

Meh

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Your peers make it worth coming into work. The benefits are good when compared to other companies in the industry, however they have cut them regularly since I started.

Cons

Micromanagement is the Amica way. They do not like autonomy and they only want yes men. If you push back on anything status quo, no matter how much it may benefit others (speaking as a prior supervisor), you will be blacklisted. If that’s not enough for you, here’s a bit more: WFH - Amica put everyone in WFH to keep business going during Covid. However there was very little effort to keep up engagement and as such, the company was very quick to start forcing people back into the office ASAP. Some departments allow two days a week WFH, but there’s no consistency. Company line is that the amica culture requires people back in the office, so there is zero consideration for more than one day a week WFH in most offices/departments and hybrid is out of the question. However they allow full time WFH for the employees from the branches they just closed…because it benefits the company. Pay - below industry standards. WAY below. Used to be able to say the benefits made up for it, but they don’t make up for it as much as they used to. Promotions - zero consistency here. If you get in with the right manager or are willing to move all the time, you’ll promote. Otherwise you’ll be told you’re doing great, they wish you could promote you, you’re already performing at the next level, but keep working hard for those 2.8% merit increases…And you can work your tail off and be a “superstar” and they’ll just give you more work to do without any additional recognition. Conversely I’ve also heard a supervisor say they couldn’t give a promotion because they have different standards and higher expectations than others. So if you get on their team, you’ll have to work harder to get opportunities given to others. How is this okay? Work/life balance - better in some departments, not so good in others. My current department has people logging in and working late most days, logging in at night, logging in on the weekend, working while on vacation (when they even take vacation…). I am able to get all of my work done in my working hours, so I can live my life outside of work - not sure if people just aren’t efficiently working or their workloads are that much more than mine. Either way - this is not okay. Pricing issues impacting goals - many years ago amica lowered underwriting standards so we could grow. Unfortunately we grew way too quickly and our loss ratios showed it. We then took the hard opposite approach, dramatically increasing rates countrywide, leading to our long term policy base - those customers who would stay with us, refer others, and were extremely loyal - to become priced out. Customers - and these were good customers - hated leaving us but could not afford us when we were $1,000’s more. We are bleeding our customers and struggling to write new policies. Tech issues - so many. So bad.

avatar
Amica Insurance Response
4y
We’re sorry to hear you feel this way about Amica, and we’d like to speak with you directly regarding your concerns. Feedback from our employees is important to us, and we want to ensure that everyone at Amica feels they are being fairly compensated, are working safely and has potential opportunities to grow at our company. Please email us at employeefeedback@amica.com so we can learn more and discuss your experience. Thank you.
4.0
Dec 3, 2023

Unrealistic

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Steady job, decent benefits, you actually get aid time.off and overtime is always available (although very short hours) and you can potentially work hybrid.

Cons

1. They threaten your job by using pto or sick time with a 'dependability' tracker. Sick? Got covid? Or need to take a personal day and use time? If the board is closed you are penalized. 2. No yearly pay raises, they do a performance review which has to do with how many life policies you get transferred. If you don't meet the goal or fall short you get a few cents. No yearly inflation increase.

avatar
Amica Insurance Response
2y
Thank you for your review. We’re happy to hear that you enjoy Amica’s benefits, our hybrid work schedule and the opportunities available to you. Amica’s success has been built on dependable service and our employees are the foundation of our success. We feel our approach to ensure our employees remain dependable and there for our customers is reasonable and appropriate. Our total rewards package includes annual performance evaluations and competitive merit-based pay increases each year for our employees. Please know that we’re always listening, and we strive to ensure our compensation plans and performance evaluations are fair and equitable. We’d like to get in touch with you to learn more about your experience at Amica. If you’re interested, please email us at employeefeedback@amica.com so we can schedule some time to speak with you. Thank you again.
Viewing 31 - 33 of 1,021 Reviews

Glassdoor has 1,071 Amica Insurance reviews submitted anonymously by Amica Insurance employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Amica Insurance is right for you.