Does Brotherhood Mutual pay their employees well?

According to anonymously submitted Glassdoor reviews, Brotherhood Mutual employees rate their compensation and benefits as 3.9 out of 5. Find out more about salaries and benefits at Brotherhood Mutual. This rating has decreased by 2% over the last 12 months.

How satisfied are employees working at Brotherhood Mutual?

90% of Brotherhood Mutual employees would recommend working there to a friend based on Glassdoor reviews . Employees also rated Brotherhood Mutual 4.6 out of 5 for work life balance, 4.6 for culture and values and 3.9 for career opportunities.

What are the top reviewed jobs at Brotherhood Mutual?

Claims Adjuster (8) , Marketing (4) , Business Analyst (3) , Manager (3) , Analyst (2) , Customer Service Agent (2) , Implementation Coordinator (2) , Intern (2) , Property Claims Adjuster (2) , Underwriter (2)

What are the pros of working at Brotherhood Mutual according to real employee reviews?

"It was a great culture" ((in 14 reviews)); "Great work life balance" ((in 9 reviews)); "Great benefits and pay." ((in 9 reviews)); "They have a great culture and people are really serious about serving the church!" ((in 8 reviews)); "Unbelievably employee friendly." ((in 6 reviews))

What are the cons of working at Brotherhood Mutual according to real employee reviews?

"Pay is a little below average compared to bigger cities, which is expected given the Fort Wayne location." ((in 7 reviews)); "Slow to change, not as competitive in salary, behind technologically, management is resistant to suggestions on continuous improvement, the expected workload is too high and out of line with industry standards." ((in 5 reviews)); "They rarely acknowledge the lack of diversity within the company." ((in 3 reviews))

What are employees saying about Brotherhood Mutual layoffs in 2026?

Explore Glassdoor’s employee reviews to understand what current and former employees are saying about Brotherhood Mutual layoffs and their outlook for job security at Brotherhood Mutual in 2026.

Skip to content Skip to footer

Notifications

Brotherhood Mutual

Brotherhood Mutual reviews

4.3

90% would recommend to a friend

(99 total reviews)

Mark A. Robison

95% approve of CEO

88% positive business outlook

Ratings by category

4.6

Culture & values

4.6

Work/Life balance

4.1

Senior management

3.9

Compensation and benefits

3.9

Career opportunities

3.7

Diversity & inclusion

Brotherhood Mutual has an employee rating of 4.3 out of 5 stars, based on 99 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an excellent working experience there. The Brotherhood Mutual employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.6 stars).

Ratings by demographic groups

Race / Ethnicity

Gender

Sexual orientation

Disability

Parent or family caregiver

Veteran status

Reviews by job title

99 reviews

5.0

Aug 12, 2011

Uncomparable to any professional company out there when it comes to business ethics, company culture, and future growth.

Anonymous employee

Recommend

CEO approval

Business Outlook

Pros

The employees are so genuine and compassionate towards their work and towards each other.

Cons

Brotherhood has a very conservative culture, but that is smart for an insurance company especially to be fiscally responsible.

5.0

May 13, 2011

I like working for a stable consistent growth company that wins in the market and does something worthwhile.

It department

Recommend

CEO approval

Business Outlook

Pros

Growth - hiring every year without downsizing Annual reviews - every year like clockwork and managers are graded on quality Annual compensation increase with the review Good benefits - not stellar, but not bad Bonus program - A formula is used at end of year and all employees get the same % (up to 20% of salary)

Cons

conservative approach to change - insurance is not prone to risk sometimes tolerate poor performance from 'nice' employees

3.0

Oct 13, 2010

OK - Not for the ambitiously, aggressive professional.

Anonymous employee

Recommend

CEO approval

Business Outlook

Pros

No pressure. work at your own pace. Good place to work until you retire - if you're not ambitious and are just looking for a paycheck.

Cons

Overly conservatiive in everything! No clear path for career development. No opportunities for growth. Favoritism among management. Too slow to adopt and innovate. Talent and knowledge is greatly under-utilized because of company's conservative culture Radical ideas are DOA Latest industry and business practices are non-existent. Lack of workforce diversity (racial). Women make up majority of BMIC employees esp. in low paying jobs but not in management. Pay not as great.

Viewing 97 - 99 of 99 Reviews

Top companies for "Compensation and Benefits" near you

Liberty Mutual Insurance

3.8★Compensation & Benefits

Progressive Insurance

3.9★Compensation & Benefits

USAA

3.8★Compensation & Benefits

Travelers

4.2★Compensation & Benefits

Jobs at Brotherhood Mutual

Quality Assurance Analyst I

Associate Data Scientist

Brotherhood Mutual reviews FAQs

Reviews Brotherhood Mutual reviews

Brotherhood Mutual

Brotherhood Mutual reviews

Ratings by category

Ratings by demographic groups

Reviews by job title

Uncomparable to any professional company out there when it comes to business ethics, company culture, and future growth.

I like working for a stable consistent growth company that wins in the market and does something worthwhile.

OK - Not for the ambitiously, aggressive professional.

Top companies for "Compensation and Benefits" near you

Jobs at Brotherhood Mutual

Brotherhood Mutual reviews FAQs

Want the inside scoop on your own company?

Bowls

Followed companies

Job searches

Top companies for "Compensation and Benefits" near you

Brotherhood Mutual reviews FAQs

Jobs at Brotherhood Mutual