EMC Insurance reviews

3.5

50% would recommend to a friend

(255 total reviews)

Scott Jean

67% approve of CEO

56% positive business outlook

EMC Insurance has an employee rating of 3.5 out of 5 stars, based on 255 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The EMC Insurance employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

255 reviews
3.0
Dec 8, 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I spent over 8 years at EMC and worked in multiple departments. You will be treated well by your peers and management. Workload is fair and you will practically never work past 4:30 or your desired end time. Benefits are great, although no ability to add a domestic partner, and you'll receive a pension, standard 401k (100% match up to 4% contribution w/good fund selection), formal reward system, etc. I learned and was exposed to a lot of interesting work while at EMC.

Cons

As stated in the title, it appears that the executive leadership team and board are positioning the company for sale. Company was privately owned up until it went public in the 90s to raise capital. EMC then performed a stock buyback in 2018 and returned to private ownership. Around that same time, EMC eliminated its unprofitable Personal Lines department (generally good idea) and recently announced the elimination of its Reinsurance department (shortsighted idea). It was clear that the ELT and board had done very little research prior to announcing the elimination of the Reinsurance business because they still have not announced plans for run-off or sale and are "deciding what to do.". It was clear that the ELT was surprised to learn that obligations on Reinsurance treaties extend past the duration of the contract on both property and casualty business. Furthermore, the company has historically been owned by the Kelley family and it appears that the son is not interested in running the organization. His father stepped down as CEO around the time of the stock buyback and now sits on the board. EMC is also a historically unprofitable company., hence the aggressive "2.5% profitability by 2025" goal (which again, I believe is meant to position the company for sale). Bonuses are tied directly to overall company profitability (there is no department or personal performance component to the bonus calculation), meaning that an underwriter with a profitable book will be compensated the same as an underwriter with a losing book. How the ELT can call this a "One EMC" bonus structure while simultaneously paying contractual bonuses to the executive team is frustrating. Lastly, it is very difficult to advance your career within EMC (or any unprofitable company, for that matter). The HR and Compensation teams have a conservative stranglehold on the rest of the organization and directly impede hiring managers from selecting talent. Also, only after leaving the organization did I learn just how underpaid we were. Senior commercial underwriters with years of experience are likely still making less than $100k at EMC. Despite employing many people around the continental US, you will be paid like you're living in Des Moines, IA where the company is headquartered.

1.0
Oct 22, 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The benefits are amazing It used to be fun when the branches ran independently

Cons

New structure and CEO are destroying the company. The new diversity equity inclusion is a lie along with the we care about people. They care about the executives only - and there is a new one weekly it seems!! (They are all young white males) . Dedicated, loyal employees are overlooked for promotions for inexperienced white young men. The loyal people who really cared are leaving and Jean Scott doesn’t care as long as his private jet is fueled and ready !!!

3.0
Jun 17, 2016

outdated

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

On site training, decent wellness center, mostly given tools needed to succeed. Area I'm in is fairly flexible on work hours as long as you meet the minium. Benefits are great, there's even a pension.

Cons

Incredibly outdated language and corporate structure. Favorites are promoted over more qualified candidates. Each programming area is somehow allowed to define their own standards, nothing is standard throughout the company. Any attempt to inject new ideas or suggestions is met with the dreaded "we've always done it thusly" attitude. Hires are treated like children for their first 3-5 years, and there is no way to escape a supervisor who you don't get along with.

Viewing 22 - 24 of 255 Reviews

Glassdoor has 287 EMC Insurance reviews submitted anonymously by EMC Insurance employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if EMC Insurance is right for you.