Dark reality behind the curtain of the 'Best Workplace' illusion - Anonymous employee Aya Healthcare Employee Review

1.0
Jan 17, 2024
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Competitive compensation at a cost.

Cons

Aya serves as a masterclass in how not to run a business. Consider working here only if you have exhausted all other options. I have never worked for such a toxic, fundamentally flawed company. Aya subjects employees to enormous undue pressure, offers them zero control over situations, punishes them for unwarranted reasons, and constantly shifts priorities, fostering a poisonous and permeating culture of fear that they show no interest in changing. Despite winning awards for the “best workplace for women,” Aya fails to provide maternity leave. Aya breaks employees down well beyond healthy limits and terminates them as a punitive measure. Aya fires people on medical leave. Aya proudly boasts that they are a people-first company, but the reality starkly contrasts the positive image presented to the media, investors, and potential employees. The result is a collection of sloppy and inefficient practices that demonstrate just how unproductive a company can be. At the highest level, Aya’s leadership is deeply flawed, with minimal communication from the CEO. There is no discernible product strategy beyond the vague directive to "be nimble,” and we build whatever the CEO says we’ll build. The lack of communication between Product and Engineering leads to an organization unable to support its teams effectively. Top Engineering leadership is the most incompetent and malignant piece of the puzzle. Despite professing an agile and transparent organization where everyone is “having fun” and enabled to take ownership over their domain area, the reality is a strict command and control environment where employees lack autonomy and authority, are punished for reporting issues, suffer from unclear roles and responsibilities, and are berated for any real or perceived mistake. The politics are pervasively toxic, making it difficult to trust colleagues and engage in healthy debate. Having made teams impotent by removing all autonomy, engineering leadership is the only one allowed to prioritize work but is averse to doing so, meaning everything is #1. Priorities rarely last longer than a week and half-finished work is shelved, destroying employee morale and putting customers at risk. The level of deception is unparalleled. Perhaps having sensed that the natives were angry, engineering leadership sent an “anonymous” survey that contained employee usernames in the URL. In the weeks that followed, many employees simply disappeared. Quarterly bonuses now hinge solely on the occurrence of high-severity incidents, which happen frequently due to a lack of priority, platform stability, and observability. While positive reviews may dominate the platform, it's important to note that they mostly come from nurses, not corporate employees. Frankly, that’s also surprising, considering Aya is the defendant in a class-action lawsuit filed by nurses who cite Aya’s bait-and-switch practice of beginning a contract with a higher rate, then making a “take-it-or-leave-it” demand to accept less pay or be terminated. This is public, you can Google it. If you’re desperate for a paycheck, they do pay money but please proceed with extreme caution and keep looking for a job that actually cares about you as a person.

avatar
Aya Healthcare Response
2y
We appreciate your feedback. Aya Healthcare complies with all applicable leave laws, including paternity and maternity leave laws. Your comment regarding paid parental leave is inaccurate as Aya Healthcare does offer several paid leave options to all eligible employees. The Company also does not tolerate discrimination, harassment, retaliation, abusive conduct, or favoritism of any kind. We take alleged violations of our EEO and other related policies seriously. You can read our full EEO policy here: https://bit.ly/ayaEEOpolicy. If you would like to report an alleged violation of Aya’s policies or want to further discuss your concerns, please email our Chief People Officer, Amber Zeeb at EEO@ayahealthcare.com.

Explore other reviews about Aya Healthcare

5.0
Jul 16, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

*Good Pay *Flexibility *For my current contract I did have to wait several months to hear back for an open position *They are great at reaching out and keeping in touch regarding training modules and constantly ask for feedback

Cons

*No guarantee hours *You have to pick up your shifts through an app which isn't always great

1.0
Jul 19, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Working from home is the only real perk. The PTO policy looks good until you try to use it. Time off has to be approved months in advance, and you’re made to feel guilty for taking it because you’ll lose business and fall behind on unrealistic metrics. A benefit isn’t much of a benefit when you’re afraid to use it.

Cons

The micromanagement has reached an uncomfortable level. For years, recruiters were expected to record conversations without candidates’ consent. Now, with the new phone systems, managers can monitor text messages and listen to calls. None of this is going to improve business outcomes or recreate the profits the company saw during the COVID hiring boom. On top of that, employees are made to feel like they are constantly on performance improvement plans, with unrealistic goals that are nearly impossible to meet. Targets are frequently adjusted or moved altogether, making it extremely difficult to hit metrics, earn bonuses, or make a meaningful income. It creates a sense that no matter how hard you work, success is always just out of reach. Leadership has become increasingly unprofessional and, in many cases, unqualified. Fear and constant surveillance seem to have replaced trust as the primary management strategy. The compensation is no longer competitive enough to justify the environment. As for the “Aya Listens” surveys, it’s hard not to question whether they’re truly intended to gather honest feedback or simply identify employees who are speaking up.

4
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All