Challenging - Store Manager Casey's Employee Review

3.0
Oct 27, 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Finding the right team. Being in the right market. Development. Increasing profit. Being able to hire/fire your own staff.

Cons

Scheduling system. It seems like it works but it is not like other big-box retailers. Meaning, that the function of the scorecard is to ensure that the scheduling puts people in a place where needed and they actually work that position However, with Casey's it is just scheduling people in areas based on 15-minute increments. It does not compare your forecasted hours to whether your people work their designated job (the whole point of a scorecard). Micromanaging to an OCD level. I spend more time filling out paperwork and putting up 12+ clipboards full of information than spending time working on the floor cleaning or re-setting planos. I have 10+ emails a day from my Supervisor, which contain requests to meet her district obligations and plenty of tasks under Casey's connection to complete by certain dates. My management team is only allowed 4.25 hours a day to be a manager and the rest of the time they are excepted to be in the role of the cashier, pizza, prep, or truck. No extra time for order.

Explore other reviews about Casey's

5.0
Jul 8, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great place to work at

Cons

People were great no cons

3.0
Jul 15, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good pay, great hours, everyone is nice.

Cons

They are not able to make temporary accommodations until doctor's notes are provided even if it's something as simple as having a chair at registers, they do have a high turnover over rate but I think that is mostly from the previous people not wanting to do their jobs correctly and couldnt take criticism.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All