Smithbucklin reviews

2.7

30% would recommend to a friend

(462 total reviews)
avatar

Matt Sanderson

42% approve of CEO

44% positive business outlook

Smithbucklin has an employee rating of 2.7 out of 5 stars, based on 462 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an average working experience there. The Smithbucklin employee rating is 27% below average for employers within the Management & Consulting industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

462 reviews
2.0
Mar 28, 2017

Don't do it

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good coffee Convenient office location Nice office environment (aesthetics) No shortage of office supplies (the good kind too!)

Cons

The environment, the created sense of urgency for every task, overthinking ever single task and meeting after meeting after meeting. Such a waste of day. I came to SB to work part time because it fit my schedule. I was older and much more experienced than everyone I worked with, including my manager. Unless you know the right person or kiss up to the right people, their are no careee opportunities other than what you were hired in to do. HR places lots of emphasis on titles and it trickles down to the employees. Managers and Directors treat their employees awful and rank was regularly thrown in your face. They love to hire new grads who have little to no experience in the work force because it's easier for them to manipulate them. Do not listen to the other reviews, it IS expected of you to work on weekends or after hours. The pay is laughably low and the benefits are terrible. But again for a new grad, anything with a paycheck looks good.

3.0
Mar 17, 2017

Don't Do It.

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

-Beautiful office, decent benefits (health, PTO, etc.) -Great people. Your coworkers are great at what they do and they're fun people to spend your time with.

Cons

First of all, everyone needs to chill out. A lot of the complaints on Glassdoor are that you can't leave at 5pm, you need work all the time.....you honestly don't. It's not life or death; you should be allowed to finish up a task or project the next day if you can't get it done today. The problem is that the company culture sets everything up to seem like a fire drill. Employees who don't stay after 5pm or respond to emails on the weekend are shamed and not only is that ridiculous but it's also unnecessary because this is not an industry that requires that kind of a lifestyle. Second, the pay is *very* low. I've seen what the industry averages are like in other companies and they pay substantially less. And then they seem very shocked when you leave after 5 months because it's a toxic environment of blame, shame, long and unnecessary working hours for peanuts. Going back to my first point, people stress about everything. Everyone is always stressed out and it's like: why? Stop acting like you're doing the Lord's work. I wholeheartedly believe you should take your work seriously and give your best, but you shouldn't blow things out of proportion. Two weeks after graduating from college and starting this job, I got reamed by a client lead because I hesitated during a webinar introduction. Okay, so I'm a human person who tripped over a few words - I had to issue a formal apology to the webinar speakers who hadn't even noticed my error and were taken aback by my apology. It's truly ridiculous and extremely over the top and made me feel completely inept and incompetent which is irrational because I just tripped over two words. The last thing that just rubbed me the wrong way: in August we went for a company update meeting. The CEO spent the whole time talking about how well we were doing as a company and taking questions from employees. One employee asked why people who followed other religions were forced to use their PTO for their religious holidays when Christians/Catholics get their religious holidays handed to them without having to turn over their PTO. They basically had no answer to that and then an HR woman stepped in to condescendingly tell the employee that you can use the 3 hours of flex time you get to celebrate whatever religious holiday you want. Doesn't answer the question because Christians/Catholics are still not required to hand over *their* flex hours to celebrate their religious holidays but everyone else is. I know a lot of companies don't give other religions time off either, but I think a company that pretends to be very diverse and welcoming should take into consideration legitimate employee concerns instead of acting like employees are ungrateful. Second, at the same meeting the CEO said it was "very sad" that other executive leadership (himself, the Chief Marketing Officer, the Chief Legal Officer, etc.) would not be able to get their bonuses this year. What?! You're staring at a room full of people you only pay $45K a year to and we're all supposed to feel bad that these guys making six figure salaries aren't getting a bonus? Cry me a river.

3.0
Dec 4, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

You will get a lot of experience in the skills that employers want. If you are just starting your career (which many are here) you will interface with top executives in the company and those of your client organizations. The skills you will learn are great resume builders

Cons

Not enough people resources to get the job done right. You will be stressed out to the max with the insane amount of work that is expected to occur in a 40 hour work week. The caliber of the executive directors are hit or miss - mostly miss. You will see that individuals in manager or ED positions shouldn't necessarily be there based on their people or management skills.

Viewing 49 - 51 of 462 Reviews

Glassdoor has 468 Smithbucklin reviews submitted anonymously by Smithbucklin employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Smithbucklin is right for you.