iCIMS reviews

3.1

49% would recommend to a friend

(793 total reviews)
avatar

Jason Edelboim

55% approve of CEO

29% positive business outlook

iCIMS has an employee rating of 3.1 out of 5 stars, based on 793 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The iCIMS employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Information Technology industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

793 reviews
3.0
Apr 25, 2014

Chaotic

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Most of the time, I really do like working at iCIMS. I have a great team and manager, and I often work with very smart, capable, passionate, driven colleagues - who are good people with integrity. What I love about iCIMS the most is definitely the people. Employees find ways to have fun together with happy hours and sports leagues including basketball, softball, soccer, and probably others. The business is very results/metrics driven, but not so much that you can't let off steam by just hanging out at someone's desk or the cafeteria to unwind. Also, at least on the sales/marketing side, hard work and reaching your goals definitely gets rewarded and recognized. All this is great. However...

Cons

The best word I could use to describe iCIMS is chaotic. Internal processes are a mess due to being non-existent or not valued/enforced. Information from across departments and especially top down is messy, disorganized, and often hear-say, leaving me disoriented at the end of the day more often than not. Additionally, because important information is not communicated appropriately or timely, departments and even groups within the same department are often found doing double-work, or scrambling to pull a rabbit out of a hat. Yes, these things happen, but at what point are we allowed to say when enough is enough, and be able to actually hold senior management accountable without hearing “Oh yeah, forgot to tell you about that.” I’m actually astounded at the incompetence and complete lack of respect for their direct reports’ that some in a more senior level role are allowed to keep getting away with. Office politics, especially at the Director/C-level, are unbearable. Just let me do my work and let me do it well! Less interference, more value on employee input, would be amazing. Less shooting from the hip. Less projects that are assigned with no thought-out strategy. And please, customer success/professional services is understaffed and has been for a long long time. Do something! This is where most of the burn-out is, and probably the voices management hears the least. I really do like my job and most of my projects. But, the internal struggles, office politics, and lower than industry average pay, make it hard to see iCIMS as anything other than a stepping stone. I say this as someone who actually likes coming to work in the morning: the negative reviews are not from bitter fired employees with a chip on their should who have something to prove. They are legitimate struggles that, for the most part, speak truthfully. I think most of the “it’s just growing pains” reviews are coming from people who are still relatively new to the company and lapping up the Kool-Aid like dogs. But for veterans (which, at iCIMS, is someone who has only been there 2+ years), it’s starting to/has gone/already went sour. People are sick of the nonsense. And the company has a retention problem as a result.

1.0
Oct 1, 2021

False positivity to hide toxic culture

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

okay benefits, flexibility for working remote

Cons

the main issue is the company’s crucial departments are understaffed. basic technical support and implementation projects are on an insane delay, yet we’re expected to communicate this to customers as if it is completely understandable. iCIMS uses a lot of buzzwords to hide a toxic company culture. Pretend they want you to have a balanced work/home life but the only way to attain the unrealistic goals set by management is to work an extreme amount of overtime. Even when you hit your goals, leadership has a way of making everyone feel like they didn’t do enough.

1.0
Apr 6, 2021
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great office in Holmdel, NJ Great co-workers in mid-management and below

Cons

Once upon a time, iCIMS was an amazing place to work. Once Vista Equity Partners took over the majority stake in shares, everything that resembled the previous iCIMS has been stripped away. What remains today is a company where leadership’s actions reflect their true interests: lining their own pockets. Leadership does not have any interest in the wellbeing of their employees. You know, the people who built the iCIMS reputation for what it is today. • Lack of Direction - CEO Steve Lucas and senior leadership at iCIMS have a severe lack of strategic vision. There is one goal: increasing ARR to form the “perception” that iCIMS is a company worth buying. This word “perception” is thrown around a lot at iCIMS. You will shoot yourself in the foot many times over the course of trying to achieve this goal because of a systemic lack of strategy and focus. This schizophrenic path is costing iCIMS more and more as time goes on. Employees are burnt out and are becoming less invested in their work, great people are leaving in troublesome quantities, quality of life at iCIMS is deep in the red, process inefficiencies and disorganization have become the norm… and this is just the tip of the iceberg. • Greedy – iCIMS leadership refuses to invest in the people on the ground who keep the lights on and the company running day to day. Employees do not get any equity options in iCIMS, despite Leadership grinding everyone below them to dust trying to achieve goals which are unattainable. Moving jobs to Colorado or India are ways that iCIMS Leadership says they need to “cut costs”. On the contrary, leadership will splurge large sums of money to increase the valuation of iCIMS so potential suitors will be attracted to buying the company. These wreck less costs include: paying high-profile celebrities to attend online events (celebrities who have nothing to do with tech/HR/Talent Acquisition); Steve Lucas forcing the purchase of a large piece of software in a “you scratch my back and I’ll scratch yours” type of deal with an enterprise company, then expecting that software to be implemented in unrealistic timelines; hiring more and more C-level executives/VPs/ board members who are part of the “Steve Lucas fan club” but denying overworked teams any actual head count that is needed (the last thing iCIMS needs is more “thinkers”). • Lipstick on a pig - Leadership will attempt to brand iCIMS and themselves as "moving fast and being flexible". But anyone can see the reality of these words is truly more along the lines of "hyper-rushed, indecisive and disorganized". Even worse, nobody is help accountable for these awful decisions, which would normally cost someone their job in another company. Which brings me to my next point… • Irony of Accountability - Up and down the chain there is seemingly no reprimanding of those who cause any harm or wrongdoings at iCIMS (whether that harm is intentional or not). This is particularly ironic since “Accountability” is a core company value on the iCIMS website, also boasted by the executives.

Viewing 58 - 60 of 793 Reviews

Glassdoor has 866 iCIMS reviews submitted anonymously by iCIMS employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if iCIMS is right for you.