Great benefits and remote work, but evolving processes create confusion - Member Care Supervisor Centivo Employee Review

3.0
Jul 1, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Competitive benefits. Fully remote work environment with good work-life flexibility. Opportunity to gain leadership experience in health insurance operations. Collaborative coworkers who were willing to help one another. Fast-paced environment where you can learn a lot in a short amount of time.

Cons

As a growing company, many processes were still evolving, which sometimes created confusion and inconsistency. Communication between departments could be improved, especially when new employer groups or process changes were introduced. Some teams lacked the tools or resources needed to work as efficiently as possible. Organizational changes and business priorities shifted frequently, creating uncertainty for employees. Advancement opportunities were somewhat limited depending on department and business needs. Overall, I enjoyed the experience I gained and the relationships I built. However, there were growing pains that affected day-to-day operations and long-term stability. If you're someone who enjoys working in a startup-like environment and can adapt to constant change, it can be a good place to build your skills. If you prefer well-established processes and long-term organizational stability, it may be more challenging.

Explore other reviews about Centivo

5.0
Jul 21, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

-great benefits -company culture -work life balance

Cons

-leadership could communicate initiatives more clearly

avatar
Centivo Response
5mo
Thank you for your feedback! We're so glad to hear Centivo offers the type of culture and work life balance you value. We are continuously working to improve our communication and have recently held Employee Engagement Focus Groups to do just that. This year we will be launching an all company Intranet which should increase visibility of the key initiatives for all departments and our progress towards them.
1.0
Mar 26, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

20% of this organization is some of the most talented and hardest working people you’ll ever encounter in this industry, passionate about the quality of their work, collaborating with others, and fixing healthcare. I have a profound amount of respect for this slice of the company because of the burden that comes with being a high performer at Centivo. Pay is competitive when considering a national grade for your role, but when you’re part of the 20% I described it can still leave you with the feeling of “it’s not enough”. The medical benefits are great, I was happy with the plan’s benefits and the cost of my premiums. Your mileage may vary here as the plan you are offered depends on where you are located.

Cons

Unfortunately, the remaining 80% are middling at best or combative, unengaged, or completely out of their depth at worst. The proverb “You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink” rings true with much of the 80%. Health plan administration involves many cross-team dependencies and requires teamwork across the aisle for an organization to be successful, so you can see how this presents a huge problem. The above applies even at the leadership level, where often the leaders have zero clue what their individual contributors or even managers reporting up to them are doing, no long term goals or attainable vision for their departments, and such a severe lack of domain knowledge that they would not stand out in an in-depth interview for an individual contributor role on the team(s) they’re supposed to be leading in the first place. Some (but not all) teams face a constant employee churn and large-scale reorganizations happen once or twice a year because things just aren’t working. Sometimes the “problems” in leadership roles are rewarded with just being moved around if they are not let go. Any leadership change happens at a snails pace, even when it’s clear for multiple quarters that the respective departments cannot succeed under them. There is a total disconnect between product, operations, and engineering, which leads to product having (some) idea of what they’re administering that is totally removed from what’s actually happening, operations struggling with inefficient workflows and asks that either aren’t achievable at all or require layers of workarounds or automation, and engineering failing to drive efficiency across the organization as they lack an even shallow understanding of how health plans are supposed to operate or what the problems are. This all leads to poor quality across the board, and a significant time investment in rework that could be spent on innovating. Morale is exceptionally bad here because of some of the challenges I’ve described and greatly contributes to the churn. To briefly touch on company culture, don’t expect to ever do anything onsite, company parties, or any real perks. If you are local to Buffalo they raffle Sabres/Bills tickets, that’s about it. No 401k match at this time. No PTO payout on voluntary departure, even for rollover hours from the previous year. Dissatisfactory annual bonuses due to poor company health.

6
avatar
Centivo Response
2mo
Thank you for this feedback - it's detailed, honest, and the kind of input we need to hear. The respect you have for your colleagues comes through clearly, and we share it. Building a team that can actually fix healthcare is hard work and we know we don't always get it right. We also believe that collaboration is not a leadership responsibility alone. It's an expectation we hold for every team member. Our mission won't be fulfilled any other way, and we're direct about that in how we hire, develop, and hold our team accountable. We know these things matter and we encourage prospective candidates to ask about them directly in the hiring process. Current team members can always reach out to the People Team or share feedback through our engagement surveys.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All