McMaster-Carr reviews

2.8

29% would recommend to a friend

(1,362 total reviews)

Jay Delaney

30% approve of CEO

45% positive business outlook

McMaster-Carr has an employee rating of 2.8 out of 5 stars, based on 1,362 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an average working experience there. The McMaster-Carr employee rating is 24% below average for employers within the Construction, Repair & Maintenance Services industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

1K reviews
1.0
Dec 9, 2019
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Pay, benefits, profit-sharing, and a Monday-Friday work schedule

Cons

Everything else. Supervisors and Managers make errors and run their respective departments very poorly every day but get promoted. Employees who make errors are fired. With very few exceptions, the worker-manager relationship is one of the most adversarial I have ever witnessed. Employees don't trust management (righfully so) and as stated managers and supervisors treat the employees like dog dirt on the bottom of their shoes. I can count on one hand the number of supervisors and/or managers I had that actually believed in treating the employees with respect. Many of them are old school and either retired or getting near retirement. If you're a recent college grad from an Ivy League school, want a six figure salary out of the gate with little to no accountability other than showing up, and know how to condescend to and treat like dirt people with far more life experience than you (and far more work experience), then this is the place for you! If you start as an associate, plan on being that for the rest of your time there. There is absolutely no employee development unless for whatever reason. If you become a "favorite" of management for no legit reason (happens all the time), you can then get away with murder. I have seen some of the most productive and conscientious people treated like dirt and/or shown the door while slackers who do below the minimum are elevated and rewarded.

3.0
Jul 14, 2018
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

It is a highly overpaid customer service job. The pay is incredible for how easy the work is, tuition reimbursement, top notch insurance, clean and pretty campus. Once I got management to like me, the job got a lot less stressful and a tiny bit more interesting. They'll put you on "special projects" once they trust you, which are still quite mind-numbing, but at least break up the day, and require a smidgen of critical thinking. Also I loved my coworkers. Management is *very* hit or miss, but I liked everyone on the specialist level. They were kind, fun, and supportive.

Cons

The culture is fear-based and at times demoralizing, though that's not immediately evident (at least it wasn't to me). Upper-level management is able to establish this in a pleasant-ish, passive aggressive way. Every move you make is micromanaged. For many months I was constantly afraid of getting fired. The work is highly repetitive and mechanized but still stressful because you're expected to have close to 100% accuracy (that's not an exaggeration). The management team is mostly made up of recent ivy-league spawns. Most were perfectly nice, many were arrogant and difficult to be around. Because they're so young and the "workhorses" are closer to middle age, it made for a really bizarre and at times hostile social dynamic. I worked there for fewer than two years in my mid-twenties, so I was never on the receiving end of the toxic ageism, but it was too palpable not to notice. All that said, I *would* still recommend this to anyone who is looking for a year or two to save some money, further their education, add to their retirement pot, maybe prepare for graduate school. That's what I did and it set me up really nicely. I got out of credit card debt, I had my nice apartment on the beach, I took some classes at UCLA and got ready for graduate school. Perfect for transition. That being said, I would be deeply depressed if it were my full-time career. I felt like I was losing brain cells and replacing them with completely useless skills.

2.0
May 24, 2018
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

• Free tuition reimbursement (100% tuition+textbooks reimbursement in any subject from an accredited program as long as you get at least a D and no requirement to stay with the company) • You will never have work to do outside of work hours. • The medical and dental plans are amazing and you don't have to pay any premiums. • There is a cash bonus every year for anyone still employed on December 1st (last year each employee got a bonus of 480% of their monthly salary). • If you work in the warehouse: the people are great.

Cons

• Your job will probably be extremely boring, repetitive, and automated out of existence within 10 years. • If you work in the office: you don't really get opportunities to get to know anyone in the cubicles around you (if you're an introvert, this may be a Pro). • Career advancement decisions are made far removed from your own management team, and you don't really have any input. You may be spontaneously moved (horizontal "promotion") to a different department with 2 days notice. • You may have skills that the company needs, but they'd rather promote one of their management trainees (1st class McM citizens) into the role, rather than waste a good job on an office drone (2nd class McM citizens), or a warehouse worker (3rd class McM citizens). • The class structure mentioned in the above bulletpoint exists.

Viewing 118 - 120 of 1,362 Reviews

Glassdoor has 1,400 McMaster-Carr reviews submitted anonymously by McMaster-Carr employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if McMaster-Carr is right for you.