Nationwide reviews

3.8

72% would recommend to a friend

(5,422 total reviews)

Kirt Walker

77% approve of CEO

64% positive business outlook

Nationwide has an employee rating of 3.8 out of 5 stars, based on 5,422 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Nationwide employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

5K reviews
3.0
Sep 11, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

-Very good benefits (they match 50% of your 401k up to 6% and also have an employer funded pension). Health/Dental/Vision options are good as well. -Work/life balance is really good. Managers are flexible with doctor appointments, family emergencies, etc. -PTO is accrued, which is a great benefit for people who do not get sick or have a lot of unscheduled absences. 18.5 days off to start and after 5 + years that increases to 23.5 days. -Opportunity to work CAT duty during storms or heavy claim periods, which gives you a chance to make extra money. -They do a good job of focusing on employee engagement by planning special events and activities. -Very strong training across the board. Both internally and externally, this is an organizational strength. Felt like I was given the knowledge and tools to do my job well. -A lot of really good people work there. Formed a lot of great relationships. -Really good teamwork overall within the office. There were plenty of people who would pass the buck and take the easy way out, but for the most part the entire office worked together really well. Felt like you could ask others for help or if you had questions. -Job security is great. People will always be getting into accidents and having claims, so as long as you are doing your job to an adequate level, there isn't much threat of losing your job.

Cons

-Difficult to move up within claims organization and in general. Even getting promoted to the next title within your department is an uphill battle. Even with very good results, it takes entirely too long. A lot of people would move companies to simply get a raise. As a result, we would lose a lot of good employees and it would require everyone else to take on extra work to pick up the slack. -Very clear that upper management plays favorites. Saw people who did not deserve promotions, consistently moving up. -End of year performance evaluations are completely unfair and borderline unethical. Mentality within upper management almost seems like they are trying to keep people down and in their current roles. If you have over 80 employees, someone in the department has to be a 5 (on a scale of 1-5). When this scale was established I was not aware of any 5's and very few 4's over the course of several years. Everyone seemed to fall into the 2 to 3 category, outside of a few people who got a 4 and then the very bottom performers who would be a 1. -Pay is OK. If you want to be paid more, you have to actively seek it out (meaning getting another job offer and asking them to match or putting pressure on them to leave). -Not much opportunity to work from home outside of during snow storms or adverse weather. This job can easily be done from home and they could probably create a more loyal workforce by being flexible and giving people the autonomy to work from home occasionally. -They are very customer focused, which is obviously a good thing. However, they would only take 1 or 2 surveys a month from hundreds of customers that you might interact with. So it was pretty much luck of the draw when it came to your customer service scores. This was a large part of performance reviews and for a lot of people it was pretty unfair. On a scale from 1-10, you needed to be at a 9 or higher to really have any chance to get a better raise, promotion, good review, etc. And most of these surveys are on people that were injured by a Nationwide insured. As a result, it can be difficult to get good scores. Metrics are a bit skewed and used against you when they want to and then not really used in your favor when they are strong.

2.0
Jul 3, 2014

Stingy, hypocritical bastards

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

There are good people that work at Nationwide. I have a great set of coworkers (always have, in every role), and my boss is fantastic.

Cons

Absolutely, without a doubt, the biggest issue in that place is the senior "leadership" in the company. I don't think you could fill the smallest conference room at Nationwide with the total number of decent leaders that are part of senior leadership. They go out of their way to make working for Nationwide a miserable experience. Raises and promotions are nonexistent, yet we always have money for extravagant engagement outings and worthless trinkets that they plaster our desks with. Speaking of engagement - for a bunch of so-called intelligent senior leaders, I find it amazing that they can so grossly misinterpret engagement numbers and feedback from their employees. There is a single question in our yearly reviews that can completely negate a year's worth of work. That question is the manager's opinion on if the employee was engaged. If it is a no, kiss any pay increase goodbye. They encourage us to answer our engagement surveys honestly, yet if you are not engaged, you get shafted. Oh, engagement surveys are anonymous? Sure, try working on a team of 4 or 5 people and have your survey be truly anonymous. Upset your manager in any way and "No" on the engagement question is all the retaliation they need.

2.0
May 14, 2014

Political and Average

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

- Benefits and work life balance

Cons

- Very political, more focus on who you know versus what you do - Leaders are afraid to improve as they are very risk adverse and stuck in the past - Leaders are all in self preservation mode and are primarily driven to maintain what they have versus doing the right thing - Short sighted leaders with no "balls" to speak of. Great place for spineless passive aggressive individuals to thrive. - Old school company (publicly says all the right things but privately worships the days of the past and remind me of a high school football player who longs for the days of old ) - Words are louder than actions - Value is placed on what you say and how you fit in versus what you do and how you perform - Lots of back stabbing at executive levels and a large number of disingenuous leaders - Massive egos at the executive ranks - Executives can be bought - not so much literally but figuratively. Again massive egos, if values and pride are nonexistent then the sky is the limit.

Viewing 52 - 54 of 5,422 Reviews

Glassdoor has 6,083 Nationwide reviews submitted anonymously by Nationwide employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Nationwide is right for you.