Shelter Insurance reviews

4.0

73% would recommend to a friend

(461 total reviews)
avatar

Rockne Corbin

70% approve of CEO

73% positive business outlook

Shelter Insurance has an employee rating of 4.0 out of 5 stars, based on 461 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Shelter Insurance employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

461 reviews
1.0
Oct 15, 2019
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Absolutely zero none nada zilch

Cons

They lure you in with words like "business owner" and "entrepreneur" but the reality is they own you and everything around you even the business YOU sell. You are not on your own...you're an employee. Rates are ridiculously high and they sell the agents on selling on value that the reason their rates are Hugh is due to an awesome claims service. YEAH RIGHT it takes 72 hours just for a client to hear from an adjuster making the agent look like a slime ball sales person. Run away.

avatar
Shelter Insurance Response
6y
Our Agents are Independent Contractors whose success or failure is a result of their efforts and sales ability. We strive to provide support, guidance and encouragement for all of our Agents. Thanks for sharing your feedback with us. We wish you the best on your next endeavor.
2.0
Oct 24, 2017

Claims Adjuster

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The retirement, 401K and health insurance were great.

Cons

You had to be there long enough to benefit from the retirement packages, and they used the benefits as an excuse to give paltry raises. Each time your goals were reached, they were changed and changed and changed until they were completely unattainable. Employees break their necks, work overtime, give it everything they have until they just get so beaten down they don't care anymore. You also have to watch out for the good ole boys system, there is very little upward mobility for women and other minorities. They have a few token upper positions in a poor effort to show some diversity, but it is completely transparent, and those upper positions held by minorities are typically in HR. They have a habit of hiring managers who have little to no people skills, and chauvinism runs rampant to the point of sexual harassment. You are appreciated there as long as you don't make a fuss or ever push back, or take a stand, and once you do, you are marked as a trouble-maker, and then the goal is to find a way to either push you to quit, or micro-manage to the point where it is impossible to do your job. There is little recognition for a job well done or for staying with it.

3.0
Jun 4, 2014

optimistic pessimist

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Salary and paid health insurance. Good introduction to insurance. An office and paid start up expenses while you build your agency.

Cons

Force to travel at your own expense for home office training - If you were an independent contractor I would understand however, as an employee this is unfair. Make you think you that its your business but its not. Whenever someone else is holding the purse you don't control anything. You are unable to use your creative entrepenurial spirit because their favorite word is no while they spend money which they think is helping your agency on marketing industry known mediums that fail and are a waste of resources such as direct mail. Their validation program requires you to report 300 x-dates and sell 5 life policies per quarter. Although the premise is not bad and actually doable the problem is that your business is measured in quarters rather as a semi-annual or annual basis. In insurance you may work on people for several months before they commit. You are constantly either working on P&C or Life, not very easy to work on both when you have no book of business. On top of that they put very heavy demands on participating in the life campaigns which they have three back to back each year. The only time there is not a life campaign is during the holiday season...so you have have drum up enough life prospects to last the rest of the year. I like contests but eventually the well dries up, you contract does not say participation is required but they hold things over head and play guilt trips. This can also depend upon your district manager. If you like working independently, then go independent and not shelter. I would highly recommend going independent, most people I know gave up GREAT salaries for a huge paycut at shelter in the HOPES of creating a big agency. Most just end up having disappointment. Once you get into shelter you begin to question if so many District managers and home office staff members had successful agencies then WHY did they give up that opportunity of unlimited income potential, having their own office, agency staff, and pretty much working on their own schedule to having to report to corporate goals? I beleive most DSM's and office staff got "promoted" because they werent good agents or didn't have success. The computer and reporting system as well as the CRM "SALES" are archaic and unfortunately you HAVE to use them.

Viewing 13 - 15 of 461 Reviews

Glassdoor has 520 Shelter Insurance reviews submitted anonymously by Shelter Insurance employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Shelter Insurance is right for you.