The Bay Club reviews

4.2

81% would recommend to a friend

(1,197 total reviews)
avatar

Matthew Stevens

89% approve of CEO

80% positive business outlook

The Bay Club has an employee rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars, based on 1,197 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an excellent working experience there. The The Bay Club employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Arts, Entertainment & Recreation industry (3.5 stars).

Reviews by job title

1K reviews
1.0
Mar 31, 2025

Toxic Culture Disguised as “Blue Collar Grit”

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Free Membership and sometimes free lunch at the corporate office.

Cons

Bay Club presents itself as a company that values hard work, ownership, and team spirit, but the reality is far from it. Leadership, particularly under Matthew Stevens, prioritizes hiring yes-men who don’t challenge the status quo, creating an environment where independent thought is neither welcomed nor rewarded. The so-called “blue-collar culture” translates to exhausting 6-7 day workweeks with little regard for work-life balance. While they promote the idea of “ownership,” the actual benefits are minimal and come at the cost of selling your time, energy, and personal well-being. The execs reap the rewards of your labor while offering little in return beyond surface-level perks. If you’re looking for a place where hard work is appreciated, this isn’t it.

3.0
Aug 13, 2023
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Friendly staff, members are nice and great to talk too mostly. Free Gym membership. no penalties for calling in sick.

Cons

this list is gonna be long. First of all, Management is terrible, they will change the schedule without telling you, they act as if the club is perfect and if something isn't right, its your fault. They expect the top notch work while paying the legal minimum. I am sure if they could legally pay less, they would. They dangle promotions and raises in front of you but never actually follow through with them. They never thank you for working your butt off. For example the CEOO was coming in for a tour and they made us do super hard work to get the club looking perfect (which I think we shouldn't have even done since that is just painting a picture for the CEOO and not actually what the club usually looks like). After the tour, the SVP sent a email out to the management thanking them for their hard work however there was no thank you too the Associates who did all the hard work. I only found this out after one of the only good Operations Managers told me. Second, Pay sucks. for a gym that has a starting membership of 385$ a month with a 1000$ initiation fee, you would assume the associates would be paid at least 18-20$ an hour. But no, we are paid $15.50 which is the legal minimum for the county I am in. When I was hired I was told there was room for raises however after working my butt off to get those, I was told the Bay Club doesn't do raises, only promotions. At $15.50 an hour you cant even afford to live anywhere close to the club without working other jobs as well. Third, They dangle promotions in your face but never actually act upon, unless you are really liked. As soon as I was hired I worked my butt off every day. I led my team and helped my manager with things he needed done. After a few months I asked about becoming a MOD(Manager on duty). he thought that would be a good idea so I set up a meeting with the SVP to work on that promotion. The svp gave a very basic "lets have you start working on things to become a MOD" answer and than completely ignored it for the rest of her career (we recently got a new SVP). The new SVP removed that role entirely and is also having me do manager esk things with no promotion or pay raise. I'm frankly tired of it and recently haven't been working as hard as possible due to the low pay and other things I will talk about. Fourth, low staff and the management doesn't seem to care. Obviously a job paying minimum wage is going to have low staff however the work load they expect us to handle cannot be done when there are not enough staff working. the only people who are getting hired are teenagers and they cant work much due to the law which causes some hours to have not even enough staff to do basic stuff such as keeping towels stocked and cleaning up after members. Fifth, No penalties for being late, no showing, last minute call outs. Frequently the managers will say "well we have plenty of people on the schedule" which on writing we do however since there's no penalties for no shows it happens every day and it is usually the same associates who are doing it. Sometimes they will even come in and workout when they are supposed to be working however nothing is done. Sixth, The managers have no communication between each other. I can tell one manager something and than have to tell the other manager it as well. this causes issues with scheduling staff to work because one manager may say you work one day at one time and another manager will say something completely different. Seventh, Club is always in disrepair and the managers act like its ok. I have to constantly deal with members complaining about how things have been broken for months and how they are paying a lot for a membership so the club shouldn't have all these broken things. The ice machine has been broken for almost a month now and members complain every day. Machines are constantly out of order and aren't fixed for several months. There's mix matched paint on the walls, floors are disgusting, both elevators were broken for 2 weeks. Eighth, There is no way to contact HR anonymously, I have asked many times and am always told to email HR however than they know exactly who I am and the last few times I have email them, my managers are looped in without even asking me if I am ok with that.

avatar
The Bay Club Response
2y
Thank you for taking the time to share you feedback with us. We take pride in creating a positive work environment led by experienced and compassionate leaders, combined with competitive benefits for our associates. We are disappointed to hear this did not match your experience. We would like to learn more about your comments and encourage you to contact us at hr@bayclubs.com.
2.0
Sep 2, 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

-Access to entire company portfolio of fitness and recreation facilities. -Competitive healthcare options. -Department lunches and meals. -Work location flexibility. -Investment options.

Cons

Without getting into too much specific detail, I would just forewarn any potential hires that this company has grown to the status of large corporation so don't expect any recognition for your hard work and long hours. The CEO won't remember you or your name and if the company doesn't feel like you fit their needs and are not worth keeping, they will let you go. There is a lot of fraternization and cliques within the corporate office which can make new hires feel unwelcomed and isolated.

avatar
The Bay Club Response
3y
Thank you for sharing your viewpoints. At the Bay Club, we strive for inclusivity, collaboration and innovation. We are surprised to hear that this was not your experience. We would like to learn more. Please reach out to HR@bayclubs.com to share your confidential feedback.
Viewing 25 - 27 of 1,197 Reviews

Glassdoor has 1,243 The Bay Club reviews submitted anonymously by The Bay Club employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if The Bay Club is right for you.