Acuity Insurance reviews

3.8

70% would recommend to a friend

(761 total reviews)

Melissa Winter

36% approve of CEO

55% positive business outlook

Acuity Insurance has an employee rating of 3.8 out of 5 stars, based on 761 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Acuity Insurance employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

761 reviews
2.0
Jul 23, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great benefits for health insurance and 401k

Cons

The culture of the company has steadily declined over the last 3 years as they shift from an employee focused culture promoting a work-life balance to a profits only culture. Developers input on estimates for project work are ignored or not sought at all that some employees are now being mandated to work overtime/weekends to complete work with unrealistic timelines. This truly used to be be the 'Best Place to Work' that you felt like you were part of a community, but no longer. If you're looking to be stressed and burnt out, apply for a job here.

3.0
Dec 13, 2024
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Work from home, excellent health benefits, generous contributions to HSA, generous contributions to 401k, fun events.

Cons

Acuity brags about unlimited sick days, but this is mostly only beneficial for those rare illnesses that require long-term treatment. Most people take 0-2 sick days per year. But Acuity boasts about the unlimited sick days because the vacation time is pretty bad - you have to work at Acuity for 16 years to get 4 full weeks of vacation. Funeral leave is limited to immediate family/inlaws only, so if you have an aunt, uncle, cousin, or best friend die, you have to use the limited amount of vacation you have to attend their funeral and grieve for them. Whenever you do take vacation, you are stressed ahead of time trying to get your work out, but no one manages your queue or email while you’re gone, so your work piles up and you are stressed trying to catch up when you get back. There are no incentives - your pay is the same whether you did a lot of projects/mentored a new employee for 6 months/wrote a lot of new business/etc or whether you did the bare minimum just to get by. You do not get bonuses. When employees leave for other companies and then come back, they get paid more than those who've been loyal to Acuity and have stayed for years. Unlike a lot of insurance carriers, underwriters at Acuity do not have assistants or help in any way. You do everything, from the smallest processing task to being logged into a call center where any agent or insured can call to ask questions or ask for quotes their UW hasn’t given them yet, all the while being expected to also act as sales by sending gifts to your agents and going into their offices for visits, all the while being expected to actually underwrite the business that is coming in and help Acuity grow to $6b. Acuity tells their employees they “love them” by sending them candy and rubber chickens in the mail, while agents get airpods, knife sets, vacuum cleaners, etc, on top of their commissions and contingency checks. You are sometimes denied time off around the holidays in order to be available for agents and insureds in case they need to call the call center.

3.0
May 1, 2016
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The views and opinions expressed here are entirely my own and do not necessarily represent the views or opinions of Acuity. Executive leadership is top notch, proven by the companies success. They have earned numerous awards across multiple business units and are recognized as a Great Place To Work. It is a fantastic place to start a career, but depending on your career goals it may not be the best time investment for long term employment. Despite enormous growth and expansion, recent changes in hiring standards, below market salaries, and rising turnover rates of senior talent are reshaping the company culture. -Extremely generous to their employees with benefits, gifts and recognition. -Genuinely treat their employees as valued members of the organization. -Successful, stable company well suited for continued success. -Flex schedules are permitted for exempt employees. -Onsite cafeteria with many choices. -It is a great place to work if you don't mind small town life, gifts, benefits and social functions in lieu of salary.

Cons

-Severe lack of diversity, deeply hinged on small town values combined with below market salaries prevents attracting top talent. -The majority of talent comes from small upper midwestern towns, regional private and extension colleges. -Promotions based on seniority over qualifications result in a lack of leadership, standards and accountability, especially with middle management. -Work-life balance supported in theory but not in practice, options like work from home/telecommute days are not typically permitted, even during inclement weather. -No concept of compensatory time for extra hours worked. -Usage of sick time is discouraged by management even though promoted as a benefit. -IT departmental group thinking results in overly stringent security policies, aversion to adopt latest technologies, and maintaining outdated systems which hinder innovation, extending project timelines. -Projects often delayed due to lack of innovation, communication, priorities, and organization from supporting departments.

Viewing 13 - 15 of 761 Reviews

Glassdoor has 775 Acuity Insurance reviews submitted anonymously by Acuity Insurance employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Acuity Insurance is right for you.