employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer

Engaged Employer

CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer reviews

3.6

63% would recommend to a friend

(1,514 total reviews)
avatar

Mike Zukerman

75% approve of CEO

61% positive business outlook

CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer has an employee rating of 3.6 out of 5 stars, based on 1,514 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

2K reviews
1.0
Mar 22, 2015

What a Joke

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The only pro I can think of is to leave this company as soon as possible. There is no future for anyone here.

Cons

The politics are overwhelming and if you push back the powers that be will isolate you and keep you out of the loop so that you can fail.

1.0
May 17, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Pay, though do expect the occasional paycheck problem. Free parking (some perk!) You will stay busy. They have a cafeteria on site. You'll learn any job you had before was probably a good job in comparison and you'll learn from your mistake. Perfect place to work if you are trying to stay away from your family - you'll never see them, and when you do, you'll be so stressed they won't want to see you.

Cons

Many of us said as we walked by the conference rooms where they were interviewing that we felt the impulse to run in and let the candidate know to consider their other choices. As it is, new employees regularly start looking elsewhere shortly after they are trained. The expectations are completely unreal. They want you to take call after call, and tell you to do your paperwork "in between calls". There isn't any in between - especially from customers who are regularly screaming about the service or mistakes on their policies. Your choices are either to do your legally required paperwork in between calls or more realistically, during breaks and after or before work. A LOT just "gets buried" - the overworked agent either forgot or never knew. Once initially trained, there is no update training inspite of having classrooms with thousand dollars worth of equipment, unless you think an email training. For that matter, try getting the email - you may have been dropped from the list! The latest I heard was that new employees cannot take vacation for the first year - any vacation time will be assigned one day here or there by the company. Is that even legal? And these poor people don't even get two days off in a row - and are expected to work every Saturday with little to no chance of ever getting off. Don't think you will get any sympathy if you have a sick child, pending surgery, medical condition, school appointment, or three feet of snow. Your expected to be there every day, and stay later if required. In the three years I was there my health was deteriorating, as your never allowed out of that seat except your assigned break or lunch (which you may find yourself still doing paperwork). Computing system is a nightmare. There is no way to look up information on line - you have to rely on word of mouth, what you may have written on some sheet, training materials which do not cover everything, and trying to chase down a supervisor. Customers get three bills, varying amounts, no bill, or confusing letters or statements. The CEO from 3 years ago is still the signature on letters going out. Supervisors vary in quality - some are good, some should not be supervisors as their MO is to avoid answering your questions (but remind you to take calls faster). Bonuses were done away with for call agents last year so not sure if that changed. They demand you meet a certain level of "cross sales", leads to getting the customer another policy - but they have not grown the infrastructure right nor are you compensated much. Many call takers were using tactics to make their sales look higher - the "push the caller to the sales side", or "keep talking until they beg to listen so they can get off the call" were a few of the techniques. This is critical if you want a reasonable schedule and a vacation. Vacation? You need to "bid" for your vacation, so plan ahead in November, and if you don't get the bid, you are out of luck. Seriously. Not even "would you take a different week". And again, if you didn't get the email, you will wait another year. This does cause a problem when people are over the limit with vacation - they may be forced to take time off at the Company's choice -or get paid. You bid for your schedule every year too so if you have a small child - seriously reconsider this as this change happens in January. New hire pay has dropped drastically in the past three years, yet work increased tremendously - supporting two states before, now six states when I left. In the three years I worked, 44 people left out of approximately 70 in the last two. They used to be selective about new hires being licensed or meeting standards when trained. Now, any warm body with clothing on willing to take the chance is welcome. Dress has gone from business casual to ghetto. Site managment is weak and non-existent. Finally, the most chilling was the "disappearances" of employees. Some people may have deserved to be let go, but there are those who were let go for trumped up charges, usually attendance (only allowed 5 occurances for a year and that includes calling out sick). Oddly enough, if you are favored, you get to stay, no matter what your work performance is or what problems you caused. It does appear that if you are on the west coast, treatment may be better, if you are on the east coast, you really are low life stepchild. There was a program to volunteer on the outside for a good cause, but if you had a job with no backup, you could never participate. This place sounds great until you get inside. I've never ever written a review like this one, and hope I never do again.

1.0
Feb 24, 2019
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The company as a whole does an amazing job. I love the diversity and inclusion efforts, volunteerism and the abundance of ways to get involved.

Cons

Managers and Supervisors. Favorites are played above any qualifications one may bring to the table. They say that you can go to HR with your concerns, but this is not possible if you want to avoid your supervisor retaliating against you. Although your name may not be disclosed by HR, the structure of the company makes is extremely easy for the supervisor to figure out who filed the complaint. Yes, departments may be large but each department is broken up into smaller teams of about 6-10 people each reporting to one specific supervisor. With that being said, it makes it pretty easy to figure out who has filed the complaint and I have seen such retaliation in action on multiple occasions. The supervisors will then freeze you out, overwhelm you with work (even more than usual), become less available to provide approvals that must go through them, they will find any reason possible to fail your QARs (audits), and it feels as if they fudge our weekly and monthly reported stats. Rather than taking the average of stats across the week or month, they just use numbers each Monday for the week and then randomly select a day to pull numbers from for the monthly reporting. This is in no way an accurate representation of your work as a whole. They also focus WAY too much on hard numbers and don’t take into account all the excess work we do that they system doesn’t account for. Oh, you were stuck taking a statement for over an hour so you didn’t complete as many daily activities? That counts against you because they don’t account for the time you had to spend in one claim alone. They use these numbers and statistics for their baseline of evaluating your worth as an employee. If you don’t perform well enough at your job, you’re in the hot seat. But if you preform too well, the supervisors become threatened by you and find any way to keep you down and punish you for fear of their own status.

avatar
CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer Response
7y
We do not tolerate the conduct you describe. We currently have no awareness of such behavior and would appreciate the opportunity to investigate further. Allegations like this should be reported via our anonymous ethics hotline which is available to all employees on our employee intranet. Of course, anything reported is fully investigated and addressed, as appropriate.
Viewing 16 - 18 of 1,514 Reviews

Glassdoor has 1,704 CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer reviews submitted anonymously by CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer is right for you.