Smithbucklin reviews

2.7

30% would recommend to a friend

(462 total reviews)
avatar

Matt Sanderson

42% approve of CEO

44% positive business outlook

Smithbucklin has an employee rating of 2.7 out of 5 stars, based on 462 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an average working experience there. The Smithbucklin employee rating is 27% below average for employers within the Management & Consulting industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

462 reviews
1.0
Sep 29, 2021
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

You inevitably learn a lot and grow in the industry over time because of your exposure to the work itself. A lot of the people that work here were wonderful colleagues.

Cons

Make no mistake, "overwork and underpay" is the business model. You will be given 60 hours of work without being eligible for overtime - then you will be called deficient for falling behind. There is no infrastructure to support employees. This cycle of gaslighting and harassment goes on until you quit or get fired. Almost no opportunity for company advancement unless you get extremely lucky. You have to politically claw for promotions. The "merit increases" should be insulting to anyone who has experience working elsewhere. HR paints themselves as a cutting-edge department that cares about and serves their employees, but they just churn and burn through entry level talent that truly doesn't know any better. This firm is a wolf in sheep's clothing.

1.0
Oct 10, 2018

The churn and burn is real

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Good location, good experience (but, depending on your department, any successes you make will likely be in spite of managers/leadership, not because of good mentorship or support

Cons

-Workload is extremely unrealistic and unevenly distributed, even within the same department. -Leadership compounds workload problem. Managers are too overloaded to effectively people manage. Certain directors actively interfere in employees’ ability to do the work. -Some members of leadership make borderline inappropriate advances toward mid-level/junior staff (who are mostly young women. -HR exists to carry out whims of directors/unit heads. Does not ensure proper conduct of managers/directors toward their employees. -Rampant and endemic high turnover. -Appalling gaps in benefits, e.g., no recognized pregnancy leave. Women must take it as a short-term disability.

1.0
May 17, 2023
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

in-building cafeteria with great food options.

Cons

Training: there is no training at all. everyone is expected to train themselves without guidance or support, while projects are thrown at them. If you do not know how to do something it is counted against you as a failure. Managers: Lack of transparency and a tendency to scapegoat, micromanage and belittle employees. Managers held employees to higher standards than they did themselves and often publicly called subordinates incompetent. Workload / Work-life Balance: there is none. employees are slotted to 5 or more clients with each client having the work of at least 2 people. with so many tasks, it can be difficult to stay on top of things and you are constantly told to be a team player, or that everyone else has the same amount of work so why can't you keep up? In this environment, it is impossible to complete everything in an 8 hour day and if you do not you are written up. Hybrid - Work Environment: the managers have a list that gets printed from the building every week and tells them who shows up and who doesn't. If you do not show up you are written up, however, write-ups are not done for everyone. Mandatory in-office days are only enforced for some employees, favoritism is a factor here.

avatar
Smithbucklin Response
3y
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We take all reviews seriously, especially negative ones because it is not the work environment we want to perpetuate at Smithbucklin. We offer a robust three-week orientation schedule for all new employees, followed by unit and client training for several weeks. In situations such as this, we encourage any employee with concerns around orientation, training, and workload to engage in an open discussion with their reviewing supervisor, HR business partner, or senior executive to identify solutions or changes. We also survey employees three times a year and take action based on feedback; we look forward to reviewing and responding to our May 2023 employee survey.
Viewing 13 - 15 of 462 Reviews

Glassdoor has 468 Smithbucklin reviews submitted anonymously by Smithbucklin employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Smithbucklin is right for you.