Amica Insurance reviews

3.9

74% would recommend to a friend

(1,020 total reviews)
avatar

Edmund (Ted) Shallcross III

81% approve of CEO

74% positive business outlook

Amica Insurance has an employee rating of 3.9 out of 5 stars, based on 1,020 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Amica Insurance employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Insurance industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

1K reviews
1.0
Apr 26, 2022

Hoodwinked

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

It is not a good place to be.

Cons

I couldn’t figure out how people continue on in the Amica environment. It is a toxic at best. The long term “tenured” employees, mostly managers, will tell you canned hype about how the company culture is the best, that everyone is like a family, that it is fun and there is a framework of support because everyone is in a brick and mortar building together - just a desk away. I believed them, I looked for this amazing supportive environment, but it just isn’t true. Maybe it used to be good at some point, but it is not like that now. Newer employees are struggling and most are not able to meet the impossible standards set for them. There is a very large turnover of employees - both managers and workers. Fair warning - be very sure you want this job, because once you have obtained your license, you will have to pay them $1000 to leave. You will literally have to pay them to leave. Learn from those before you - it does not get better - it is not worth the allure of pay, benefits, bonuses and training. As a new hire, there is training to take billing calls and learning the systems. Training is rushed, the training system rarely works and you will be told there is no way to train for the calls you will take. You will not feel ready to take calls, but off you go. Many of the callers have received cancellation notices, are upset that their rates have increased or just want to be mad. If someone tells you that the customers are all very nice - do not believe them. Next, you will “graduate,” to start training to obtain licensing and are then able making changes to policies. They show you how to do something once during training and after that it is practice on your own. While taking calls, expect to feel really really bad for asking any questions of management. Try to figure it out quickly on your own while a person is on hold and make sure you don’t take a lot of time doing it because hold times, after call times, in call times, outbound call times, away from desk times - everything is monitored to the second. If someone tells you not to worry right out of training , that they aren’t watching your metrics - Do. Not. Believe. Them. They are watching and will let you know of all mistakes made and how they expect you to improve, these mistakes will also affect your metrics. At this level you will be at a more intense part of customer calls. Customers will be very upset more often and managers are reluctant to help. After a short period of time, you will have no choice but to continue on to “utility” training where you will be expected to know it all. You will get the complicated/problematic calls, you will be the person people call and expect to know the ins and outs of all that is insurance. In training you will again be shown how to do complex transactions once, again be left on your own to “practice” and once taking these calls managers are even less responsive to questions. The intensity of expectations increases at each stage and once finished, the laundry list of what is expected daily and in each call is impossible to accomplish. Emails are sent about taking too many breaks, Skype messages are sent asking why taking so long, meetings will be made to discuss your performance and managers rarely leave their desks. A hiring manager may tell you that as a call center rep you do not have to solicit insurance. Do. Not. Believe.Them. There is an insurmountable amount of pressure to solicit every single call you receive and make. Managers will tell you it is easy, all you need to do is ask and how well they performed once upon a time when they were in your position or about a past employee that got hundreds of successful solicitations. Life insurance is number one, sell sell sell - just ask - even the woman that just lost her husband, she needs to think about life insurance - get the sale. If you aren’t able to meet the goal, even if you give the highest form of customer service and the customers adore you - your performance will be based on whether you met their metrics. They make it seem that it is intentional and that you are not trying, they will change what qualifies for metrics and will give the same unhelpful answers if you voice your struggle. There are high pressure office “games” for solicitation performance and dozens of emails every week. The goal is a moving target. When working for Amica do not expect consistency, expect a new manager ever month, expect work life balance to be used as leverage, expect to feel disposable, expect to feel like an idiot on a regular basis and expect no matter how hard you try or how clear you communicate you’re struggling - to be told it is you that is the problem or even worse - ignored completely. Six different managers in the first six months, enough said.

avatar
Amica Insurance Response
4y
We’re sorry to hear you feel this way about your time at Amica. We take concerns like the ones you shared in your review very seriously, and we’d like to hear from you directly to learn more about your specific experience. Please email us at employeefeedback@amica.com so we can discuss this with you further. Thank you.
2.0
Dec 2, 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The healthcare benefits are amazing.

Cons

Are you an effective worker who is able to finish all of your work and then some during your regularly scheduled hours? Don’t think this will be celebrated - you will be asked why you don’t work more hours or send emails outside of your scheduled working hours. Do you enjoy meeting goals set by your manager? Too bad - the goal posts will change once you meet them so you will never actually meet them and you will be chastised accordingly (even when you have documentation of the original goals). Do you like promoting regularly? That’s great if you’re a white male, suck up, or able to move every year. Instead you’ll hear regularly throughout your career that you are amazing and they wish they could promote you - in fact you’re already working at the next level - but there’s just not the ability to promote. Do you enjoy improving work flows and processes to help everyone work more efficiently? People who push against the status quo do not succeed here. You need to be a yes man to move up. Don’t believe all of the recent positive reviews. I’d bet that the company rewarded employees to write them instead of actually fixing the problems in the company.

avatar
Amica Insurance Response
3y
Thank you for your review. We’re sorry to hear you feel this way about your time at Amica. We’re an equal opportunity employer and are committed to an inclusive workplace. We post for positions internally and review our career lattices regularly to ensure that there are opportunities for advancement for our employees . We’re always looking for honest and open feedback about employees’ specific experiences with the company, and we do not reward those who leave positive reviews. We’d like the opportunity to discuss your experience with you in more detail as well. Please email us at employeefeedback@amica.com so we can learn more about the comments you shared. Thank you again.
2.0
Aug 5, 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Benefits, amount of time off given, benefits start day you start

Cons

Where do I begin? This workplace was AMAZING when I started over 3 years ago. I wanted to retire here and told everyone how much I loved my workplace. Now I tell them quite the opposite. You get plenty of time off but the board is open to use it maybe 2 months of the year cumulatively. Management is generally lacking knowledge and unable to help you in a lot of situations. Plus there's a lack of managers so they're all constantly behind on getting files back to you. My biggest con that has me job searching? The lack of ability to work fully remote. It worked during the pandemic, I even got a promotion while at home, so obviously I work hard (actually harder) while at home but that doesn't matter. They insist due to culture we need to be in office. My team, including management, is spread between 3 states so not sure what extra culture I get by being in an office of people I don't directly work with anymore other than their culture of germs. I'm disabled and immunocompromised and it's been a battle to get ADA forms for WFH accomodations approved. There's just no wiggle room in their minds about it and that's apparent as a common trend through all of these reviews, to which they reply with "we are listening" and "we value your feedback" but have not budged from 3 days in the office and 2 at home. As others have also said, the pay has not been adjusted to offset the inflation we are all experiencing right now. Retention bonuses were laid out for the year but are heavily taxed and don't end up even touching what we would save if allowed to just stay home. It's a stress that we are all feeling and could so easily be relieved but isn't because of "culture". Due to the above, we are so short staffed and therefore way overworked. Our long-term insureds are seeing it too and the amount of people I've heard say Amica is not what it used to be is appalling. We pride ourselves as a company on excellent customer service and the insureds are just not receiving that anymore. I went from wanting to retire here to pulling my hair out everyday stressing over this job.

avatar
Amica Insurance Response
3y
Thank you for taking the time to write this review. Please know that Amica fully complies with the ADA. If you feel you have a disability requiring accommodation, please speak with your manager. While we understand that you may not think it will make any difference, we’d like you to know that we truly do listen to our employees, so we would welcome the opportunity to speak with you. The feedback we’ve received from our employees has already helped us make changes to our work-from-home program, and some positions here are now currently fully remote. If you’re ever interested in getting in touch with us to share more about your experience, you can email us at employeefeedback@amica.com. Thank you again.
Viewing 19 - 21 of 1,020 Reviews

Glassdoor has 1,070 Amica Insurance reviews submitted anonymously by Amica Insurance employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Amica Insurance is right for you.