Madison Reed reviews

3.8

73% would recommend to a friend

(290 total reviews)

Amy Errett

75% approve of CEO

66% positive business outlook

Madison Reed has an employee rating of 3.8 out of 5 stars, based on 290 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Madison Reed employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Retail & Wholesale industry (3.4 stars).

Reviews by job title

290 reviews
3.0
Nov 11, 2015

CC memberss.

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Worked with some of amazing people. Amy is amazing and has great people skills. Fun office environment. Some of the Leads were amazing

Cons

Color crew members need to learn how to be more organized. No organization, Management didn't know how to humanize their employees. Leads didn't get enough credit. Not very diverse

1.0
Dec 18, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

They pay well and they have good benefits

Cons

Lack of consistency in terms of policies, Employees are consistently permitted to bypass their direct manager any time they are dissatisfied with an outcome. There is zero disciplinary action, there are employees who have several “final” write ups but management has to fight to terminate terrible team members and are always denied, even though where I am is an at will employment state. Insubordination, no call no show, didn’t matter. HR makes it impossible to clear out the bad apples.

avatar
Madison Reed Response
4mo
Hello there, thank you for your feedback! We value the trust you place in us by sharing your thoughts. If you’re willing, we’d love to dive deeper into your comments. Please feel free to reach out to hr@madison-reed.com; we’re here to listen. Kindly, The People Team at MR
1.0
Dec 7, 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

•A few good people trying to survive the system. •The mission sounds nice on paper.

Cons

• Employees were pushed into signing an arbitration agreement disguised as the “2025 Employee Handbook,” without any warning or even a clear explanation that this meant giving up the right to pursue individual or class-action lawsuits. Leadership loudly announces minor changes, but this major legal waiver was buried, rushed, and incentivized with fringe points to pressure people into signing quickly (you can see this on CoCo 2025). • Expect constant goalpost-moving. Standards change weekly — sometimes daily — and employees are held accountable for rules that didn’t exist the day before. Policies shift without notice, expectations are unclear, and management still claims you “should have known.” The environment feels unstable on purpose. • I experienced open racism from both a client and a coworker, and nothing was done. Management & HR avoided addressing it entirely, offered no support, and never followed up. Protecting the company’s image took priority over protecting employees’ well-being or basic dignity. • Management culture is punitive, not supportive. PIPs are used more as disciplinary weapons than development tools. These PIPs create a climate of fear where employees feel (and in some cases just are) set up rather than coached. I was being paid to intimidate and performance-review less-than-loved employees for voicing their well-founded concerns (like their inability to take a lunch break). • HR does not function as a neutral party. Reporting issues leads nowhere, and it’s clear the system is built to protect the company, not employees. • Psychological safety is nonexistent. • Ethical red flags. You can be pressured to carry out directives that feel discriminatory or professionally irresponsible. Voicing a concern is not welcome.

avatar
Madison Reed Response
4mo
Hello there, thank you for your feedback! We value the trust you place in us by sharing your thoughts. If you’re willing, we’d love to dive deeper into your comments. Please feel free to reach out to hr@madison-reed.com; we’re here to listen. Kindly, The People Team at MR
Viewing 43 - 45 of 290 Reviews

Glassdoor has 293 Madison Reed reviews submitted anonymously by Madison Reed employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Madison Reed is right for you.